One would think that I, a committed Christian with a principled anti-abortion position, would be pleased at the prospect that the Supreme Court seems poised to overthrow Roe v. Wade. Instead, I find myself experiencing unanticipated ambivalence.
Changes in human law on such a moral question mean little or nothing unless there are also changes in the human heart. In a society where it is widely held that aborting a pregnancy is a woman’s inherent right, it is doubtful whether reduced access to legal abortion will actually lead to fewer women terminating their pregnancies.
In all the politicization of the abortion debate, the radically-biblical perspective has been almost completely absent. Part of the problem, it seems to me, is that Christians have focused on the question of when life begins.
While the traditional view of Christians is that life begins at conception, the Bible does not provide definitive support for this position, beyond its undoubted acceptance of the developing fetus within the womb as, in fact, a child (particularly in Jeremiah 1:5; Galatians 1:15; Luke 1:41, 44).
Americans are not likely to agree on when life begins, because we have so many views (movement, heartbeat, viability, etc.). Perhaps it would be helpful to shift focus to a question for which there is a more ready answer. In the Judeo-Christian tradition, it is an article of faith that human beings are created imago dei, “in the image of God.” Rather than “when does life begin?”, one might want to ask, “when is the divine image ‘imprinted’?”
Here what the Scriptures say is more helpful. We’re told in Genesis that “God created man in his own image; in the image of God he created him: male and female he created them.” Within “man” (that is, the human species) there is a differentiation that is somehow an integral part of God’s image. This is usually taken by theologians to mean that God’s image is most fully revealed in the complementarity of the two sexes.
But if the complementarity of the sexes, essential to the fullness of the divine image, is found in union of male and female through coitus, then a new being is created in God’s image at the instant when the male sperm and female ovum unite. In other words, that image is imprinted at conception.
With this understanding, it is not simply life in the womb that Christians defend, but a being made in the very likeness of God. It is a being truly sacred and deserving of our every effort to keep it viable — and inviolable — from that moment all the way through to the grave.
Christians who hold this view, because of its essentially religious nature, have no power to force it on others, nor should they seek to. But we can and must advocate it, and make the argument for it in a clear but compassionate way. The takeaway is that the new being in the image of God conceived within a woman’s body is most emphatically not hers simply to dispose of as she wishes.
If the growth and development of that being threatens hers, then she (and her partner) are faced with a decision in consultation with medical professionals: will she risk her life for the new creation in the image of God within her, or will she save her own life at the cost of terminating her pregnancy? As Christians, we are called voluntarily to lay down our lives for others, but a mother in a truly life-threatening situation who does not make that choice ought not to be faulted.
Pregnancies resulting from rape or incest raise additional, truly gut-wrenching, moral difficulties. Despite the perverse manner of their cause, the image of God is nonetheless re-produced through the sexual act. With that in mind, divine-image-based decision-making counsels that the pregnancy go to term, with the option of putting the baby up for adoption at birth.
If the mother cannot be persuaded to choose that course of action, the compassionate response is to allow early termination of such a pregnancy as a last resort. God is merciful, and we can be sure that he will be so to both mother and child in such circumstances.
Unless and until hearts are changed to recognize the inviolability and sacredness of the divine image in which each of us is made, merely changing the law on abortion strikes me as the proverbial re-arranging of the deck chairs on a sinking Titanic.
Fr. John A. Porter is an Anglican priest, writer, editor, and translator who lives in Mt. Lebanon.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.