He didn’t have to say any­thing. It was just one of the hun­dreds of feel-good sto­ries the Amer­i­can press pro­duces ev­ery day. But con­tro­ver­sial psy­chol­o­gist and pub­lic in­tel­lec­tual Jor­dan Peter­son just had to jump in.

“Sorry. Not beau­ti­ful. And no amount of au­thor­i­tar­ian tol­er­ance is go­ing to change that,” he tweeted in re­sponse to an­other tweet on the plus-size model Yumi Nu ap­pear­ing on the cover of Sports Il­lus­trated’s swim­suit is­sue. As of this writ­ing, the tweet has over 5,000 retweets, al­most 11,000 quote tweets, and over 65,000 likes.

Mr. Peter­son hit on a com­bi­na­tion of mi­sog­yny and cru­elty (“not beau­ti­ful,” mean­ing ugly) and re­sent­ment (“au­thor­i­tar­ian tol­er­ance”) that roused his fol­low­ers. “Don’t let the woke­sters make you say a fat girl is pretty” is a fair sum­mary of many of the re­sponses.

It was an un­for­tu­nate state­ment from a man who has made mil­lions on books — “12 Rules for Life” and “Beyond Order: 12 More Rules for Life” — that urged a con­sciously old-fash­ioned way of liv­ing. The books seem to have done much good, es­pe­cially for young men who had not learned such rules in their up­bring­ing.

Advertise with us

Among the old-fash­ioned ways, how­ever, are the rules of chiv­alry. These in­clude “Do not in­sult a woman’s looks,” and “Don’t say some­thing hurt­ful when you don’t have to.” So­ci­ety de­pends on rules like these to keep peo­ple from hurt­ing and even­tu­ally hat­ing each other.

Mr. Peter­son seems to have missed these les­sons, or de­cided he didn’t like them. I can imag­ine my father’s look had I said what Mr. Peter­son said. It’s a look I worked very hard to avoid.

Mr. Peter­son treats some­thing so­cially con­structed and cul­tur­ally rel­a­tive as if it were an eter­nal truth. “Not beau­ti­ful,” he says. “Says who?” says I. We don’t know how he de­fines beauty, but his idea clearly does not in­clude larger women. It does for many other peo­ple, in­clud­ing the ed­i­tors of Sports Il­lus­trated. Tastes dif­fer. A lot. Mr. Peter­son should know that.

One of the fun­ni­est re­sponses to his tweet was, in Peter­so­nian form, “Re­ject moder­nity, em­brace tra­di­tion.” And then showed Renais­sance paint­ings of vo­lup­tuous women. An age he ad­mires — an age in­tensely in­ter­ested in beauty — had an ideal of fem­i­nine beauty dif­fer­ent from his. A wise man would learn from that.

Mr. Peter­son’s ab­so­lu­tiz­ing of his own tastes is a prob­lem in it­self. It’s an in­tel­lec­tual weak­ness. But it’s not the main prob­lem with the tweet.

Advertise with us

The main prob­lem is the rea­son he tweeted it. Why did he tweet that com­ment? Be­cause he gave into temp­ta­tion. After read­ers re­acted to his tweet, Mr. Peter­son noted the way Twit­ter en­cour­ages peo­ple to blurt out their first re­ac­tions. “The in­cen­tive struc­ture of the plat­form makes it in­trin­si­cally and dan­ger­ously in­sane,” he said.

True. Un­for­tu­nately he was speak­ing of the crit­i­cism he got — “an end­less flood of vi­cious in­sults” — and not his own tweet. He started the fight, and then acts as if he didn’t.

Why did he give in to temp­ta­tion? Be­cause he saw a chance to chal­lenge “the woke.” I sus­pect the third sen­tence of that tweet was the im­por­tant one to him.

He seems to have thought that the mag­a­zine fea­tur­ing such a model on its cover meant to im­pose its “woke” view of fem­i­nine beauty. That’s the only way he can ex­plain the ed­i­tors put­ting Ms. Nu on the cover, in­stead of a clas­si­cally thin but buxom young woman.

The cul­ture-war­ring in­stinct runs deep in Mr. Peter­son. Deep enough to drive him to in­sult a young woman of whom he had no rea­son to speak at all. But she’s not the point. At­tack­ing the woke­sters is the point.

Advertise with us

When our young­est child was four, we were at some event with lots of peo­ple man­ning ta­bles. One man had a badly de­formed nose. Our son said, loudly, maybe five feet away from the poor man, “Mommy, what’s wrong with that man’s nose?” His older sib­lings nearly stran­gled him.

My son was four and as yet un­clear on what you could say to peo­ple and what you couldn’t. He was a very kind child, but he did not yet know how to speak kindly. Jor­dan Peter­son is an in­tel­lec­tual. He was a re­spected pro­fes­sor of psy­chol­ogy in Can­ada’s ma­jor uni­ver­sity. Events threw him into the spot­light and he pro­ceeded to make him­self fa­mous and wealthy. He be­came a guru, and a hero to the en­e­mies of wo­ke­ness.

But in the pro­cess he for­got what he should have known: that the world looks dif­fer­ent to dif­fer­ent peo­ple. And that car­ing about how other peo­ple feel isn’t au­thor­i­tar­ian or woke, but kind­ness. And that peo­ple de­serve kind­ness, and so­ci­et­ies de­pend on it.

David Mills is the as­so­ci­ate ed­i­to­rial page ed­i­tor for the Pitts­burgh Post-Ga­zette. He can be reached at dmi­lls@post-ga­zette.com.