Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center in Beaver County, like hundreds of other skilled nursing facilities throughout the country, suffered a severe outbreak of COVID-19 in spring 2020 that tragically took the lives of many of our residents. Although we implemented infection control procedures recommended by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention and state health officials, the novel coronavirus presented unprecedented challenges unlike anything our industry has ever faced. In confronting these challenges we moved swiftly, doing our best to control the disease’s spread and treat infected patients given the information and resources we had available to us at the time. Sadly, the virus spread early despite our best efforts, and we deeply regret the loss of life that resulted. We have always prioritized the safety of our patients and employees above all else and will continue to do so.

The sad reality of COVID-19 is that the more residents a nursing home has, the greater the likelihood the facility suffered more deaths as a result of this virus. Brighton is the third-largest nursing home in Pennsylvania, and the two larger nursing homes in the commonwealth reported more COVID-19 deaths. In fact, seven additional long-term care facilities in Pennsylvania saw more fatalities from COVID-19 than Brighton. I say this not to minimize the significance of these deaths, but to illustrate that many facilities in the commonwealth and well beyond struggled to contain the virus.

Skilled nursing facilities faced unprecedented challenges at the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic as providers of medical care to the elderly, the population that is most susceptible to the virus. Brighton rigorously implemented infection control procedures very early in the pandemic. In spring 2020, regulators were concerned primarily with preserving masks for hospitals and implemented guidance in furtherance of this goal that likely contributed to the virus’s spread within nursing homes. Nursing home operators were told to preserve masks by directing employees not to wear them unless they were in direct contact with a resident who was infected or suspected of being infected. We instituted a mask policy very early because of our understanding of infectious disease transmission and our conviction that masks would be an effective tool in protecting our patients. It was understood early that the virus was most lethal to the elderly, yet official guidance and policies handicapped nursing homes’ ability to mitigate spread of the virus.

Additionally, the federal government provided very little assistance to facilities early in the pandemic when it was needed the most. I believe that creating a network of facilities for treatment of exclusively COVID-19 patients would have been incredibly effective, allowing facilities to transfer COVID-19 patients out of their buildings and minimizing the risk to residents who had not yet contracted the virus. When the federal government did not pursue this initiative, I offered to use three of my facilities in Pennsylvania for this purpose but never got a response to my offer. Worse still, at that time the federal government did not create an effective testing infrastructure, and all facilities were left to fend for themselves, sourcing testing kits from private out-of-state companies that varied in their accuracy and efficiency. It could take up to five days to get test results from these private companies, giving the virus ample time to spread through the facility during the interim.

Advertise with us

Like the CDC and the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS), Pennsylvania did its best to provide resources and guidance to facilities, but in retrospect the guidance was unhelpful and encouraged practices that contributed to the virus’s spread. I do not say this to deflect blame to regulatory agencies, but rather to recall the incredible uncertainty that existed at the outset of the pandemic. The CDC and CMS made mistakes. State health departments made mistakes. These errors were the result of an absence of information available at the onset of a once-in-a-generation pandemic. When the pandemic is over, government agencies and skilled nursing operators must collaborate to reflect on these issues and develop an actionable set of best practices that can be used in the future.

Last year, while we were devoting immense time and resources to controlling the outbreak, the federal government began an investigation into some of my skilled nursing facilities and facility employees, including Brighton. Throughout the investigation, we have been deeply troubled by the federal government’s treatment of our staff and frustrated by its unwillingness to communicate clearly with us to resolve misunderstandings and facilitate accurate information sharing. The loss of life at Brighton as a result of COVID-19 was tragic, and we are deeply saddened that we were unable to more effectively mitigate the effects of the outbreak despite our best efforts. However, we believe that the federal government is targeting Brighton’s employees for these tragic outcomes even though numerous facilities throughout the country endured equal or worse effects from the virus. I have decided to speak out because I want to inform our staff, residents and broader community about our concerns.

The federal government has threatened Brighton and people affiliated with Brighton with indictments if they do not offer evidence in support of the federal government’s theory about what happened at Brighton. Such government threats of criminal charges put people who have been under incredible stress throughout the pandemic, risking their health, and their lives, to care for patients and facing the many other challenges posed by the outbreak, under even more pressure. I am frustrated that the federal government has chosen to compound this stress by intimidating them with threats of indictment. The federal government, I believe, has made false claims and failed to request documentation we have meticulously kept throughout this extremely difficult time. That the federal government is attempting to link anything from the past to the outbreak in 2020 is completely irresponsible and wrong.

I fully understand that engaging in public spats with reporters or with the U.S. attorney’s office does nothing to control the virus or to save lives. I unfortunately can no longer remain silent in good conscience because the U.S. attorney’s office is rushing to indict Brighton employees this month, while the current U.S. attorney is still in command.

My employees have risked their lives throughout the pandemic and done everything in their power to control the virus and protect their patients. In fact, after the initial outbreak of COVID-19 at Brighton in April and May, Brighton saw one of the lowest rates of COVID-19 death among long-term care facilities in the state and in the country. This was a direct result of the infection control procedures, diligence and care our staff provided our residents each and every day.

Advertise with us

The federal government, meanwhile, provided harmful guidance from the onset, initially discouraging the use of PPE in nursing homes and abdicated responsibility for sourcing testing kits and facilitating coordination between providers. Now my employees, who shouldered these burdens without help or effective guidance from the federal government, are facing prosecution, and I feel a responsibility to tell the public. The U.S. attorney’s office intends to indict my employees for failing to contain a virus that devastated the entire industry, our country and the world. It is not right, and I will not stand quietly by while this happens.

Staff at Brighton and long-term care facilities around the country deserve nothing but our respect and gratitude for risking their lives to care for our most vulnerable as best they could. They had little support or guidance from government officials, and what they did receive early was often the wrong guidance. I stand proudly by my employees at Brighton and thank them for all they’ve done during a devastating time for our industry and the entire world.

Mordy Lahasky is part owner of Comprehensive Healthcare Management Services LLC, which operates Brighton Rehabilitation and Wellness Center in Beaver County. He lives in Long Island, N.Y.