It’s probably just as well schools aren’t in session right now. Imagine what a Sisyphean task it would be for a civics teacher to reconcile the reality of life in America today with textbooks about how democracy is supposed to be conducted in this country.

A prime example of the gap between textbooks and reality is the unidentified federal troops that President Donald Trump has unleashed on the streets of Portland, Ore., to quell dissent and, allegedly, stop agitation by “violent anarchists.”

Students who have already read and discussed George Orwell’s “1984” are familiar with the concept of “Doublespeak” and recognize it in Mr. Trump’s rhetoric about trying to “help Portland, not hurt it.”

Even the least attentive student knows that trampling the constitutional rights of protesters singled out and thrown into unmarked vans and spirited away is contrary to everything this country is supposed to stand for.

Advertise with us

On Wednesday, Portland Mayor Ted Wheeler was tear-gassed along with protesters by federal agents working for the Department of Homeland Security. Ironically, the Democratic mayor had been booed hours before by the crowd for using what many consider Gestapo-like tactics in the early days of the protests against police brutality and violence.

It would be a lot for any civics teacher to untangle. Looking at any conflict in context is bound to uncover a multitude of motives, bad faith and reasonable actions working at cross purposes, but the constitutional right to protest will take precedence.

Sooner or later, it will occur to even the dimmest student to ask the question that seems the most inevitable: “Like, a few months ago, didn’t a bunch of militia-type guys, like, turn out at the state capitol with long guns demanding their liberty because the governor asked them to wear face masks in public and stay home to flatten the curve? Like, where are these men with their guns now that Trump is threatening to loose federal troops on American streets? Seems like a punk move to just hide out in their bunkers now.”

At this point, the civics teacher can steer the class into a lively discussion about theater and the politics of fake outrage. Men and women with long guns and heavy weaponry hanging out on the steps of city hall or the state capitol are likely to run for the hills at the first sign of real tyranny. They know their guns are mostly fashion accessories.

They also know that the anonymous shock troops of the Department of Homeland Security aren’t likely to be impressed by the collective fire power of any anti-mask brigade if they were to step out of line.

Advertise with us

A good civics teacher would remind the students that this week, America was treated to the spectacle of a president sending both black-garbed and camouflaged agents without military insignia into the streets of an American city without the permission of the governor or the mayor. Lawyers will spar over the constitutionality of such an action, but historians and political scientists are unanimous that this is a step toward whatever an American brand of totalitarianism will be called.

Of course, the Republican caucus that claims to have such finely tuned antennae when it comes to “tyranny” have stayed silent.

Unlike their forerunners whose heads exploded when the late Attorney General Janet Reno sent soldiers to retrieve a Cuban refugee boy from a closet in the Miami home of his uncle, Trumpian Republicans aren’t the least bit scandalized by the president’s threats to flood the streets of Philadelphia, New York and Chicago with federal agents deputized to act with impunity.

Because those are cities governed by Democrats, the Republicans believe its in their best interests to say nothing and hope their constituents won’t notice either their extreme cowardice or their dereliction of duty under the Constitution to provide a check to presidential overreach.

A really good civics teacher would encourage his or her students to look for historic parallels in our country and other countries for insight. Since the anniversary of the Kent State massacre has been in the news recently, students might debate the similarities and dissimilarities with this week’s actions in Portland.

Advertise with us

Once the class discussion turns to another inevitable question — what kind of person would willingly cooperate in suppressing the constitutional rights of fellow Americans while wearing unidentifiable military uniforms — the interesting historical nuggets can fly.

A good civics teacher will know that a lone protester at Tiananmen Square prevented a column of tanks from proceeding to break up a historic uprising. Because the soldiers refused to fire upon their neighbors, friends and loved ones, the Chinese government brought in soldiers from Mongolia and other outer provinces to crush the rebellion.

The civics teacher will ask how many times that has happened in both world and American history. One bright student might volunteer that Nicolae Ceausescu, the executed leader of Romania, staffed his vicious secret police exclusively with orphans who had no family ties and had pledged loyalty only to him.

That provocative notion will get the class murmuring, but the conservative kids sitting in the back will not be amused or intimidated. They will make a spirited defense of the president’s circumvention of the Constitution by insisting that Mr. Trump is merely acting out of an excess of concern by sending just enough soldiers to stop Portland’s federal court building from being “burned to the ground by antifa.”

When the civics teacher finally regains control of the class and tamps down the passionate arguments, it will be time to mull over the question that will be explored in the next session: What will you do if President Trump sends federal agents wearing black and camouflage to your city? What will you do if someone you love, or even a neighbor or fellow citizen you don’t know, is spirited away in an unmarked van?

Tony Norman: tnorman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1631  Twitter @Tony_NormanPG.