Pittsburgh has a long history both with air pollution and as an important contributor to the nation’s economy.
Typically, economic performance of nations, states, and metropolitan areas is measured using Gross Domestic Product (GDP). For decades, such statistics have influenced decisions made by central banks, elected officials, investors, and the lay public. Their importance cannot be overstated. We propose an adjustment to this official economic performance metric: the subtraction of pollution damage (a hidden cost) from GDP.
When applied to the U.S. economy as a whole, we find that air pollution damages comprise a significant share of GDP, and that these impacts fell considerably in recent years. We focus on the Pittsburgh region to demonstrate how a more inclusive measure of metropolitan economic performance might affect our sense of economic development in the region.
Why subtract damages from GDP? While firms (and, indirectly, households through higher prices for cleaner products) in the region have invested in pollution control, this study values costs from remaining emissions. Given our current regulatory structure, firms do not pay to emit. Without such payments, the cost from damages from remaining emissions after pollution controls escapes traditional measures of output like GDP.
The analysis begins by using computer models to estimate the health damages from exposure to fine particulate matter (PM2.5) air pollution in the seven county metropolitan area (Allegheny, Armstrong, Beaver, Butler, Fayette, Washington and Westmoreland counties). The data include the three most recent years for which nationally comprehensive pollution emissions data are provided by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency: 2008, 2011, and 2014. Using national emissions data is important because it allows the analysis to show how much of the damages in Pittsburgh are coming from outside and inside the metropolitan area.
Importantly, PM2.5 concentrations in the metropolitan area fell between 2008 and 2014. Connecting concentrations to health effects relies on research from public health studies. This is an area of research that extends back at least to the early 1970s, when researchers at Carnegie Mellon University demonstrated that particulate matter elevates mortality risk. We then convert increases in mortality risk into monetary damages, /while such measures have important uncertainties and do not include every effect that pollution may have, they are regularly used in peer-reviewed research and government reports.
The results of this exercise are surprising.
From 2008 to 2014, the measure of regional performance that accounts for air pollution impacts grew far more rapidly in Pittsburgh than official GDP. Between 2008 and 2011, this measure grew twice as fast as GDP. So contrary to conventional wisdom, accounting for environmental quality does not always diminish economic growth. When economies clean up, growth is enhanced. Had air pollution worsened over this time, accounting for pollution damage would have slowed Pittsburgh’s growth.
This is not to suggest that Pittsburgh’s air quality is good enough. Rather, improvements have occurred and are a valuable contributor to the region’s economic performance, even if they are not registered in official economic accounts.
By separating out local and imported emissions, we find that the costs from imported pollution into the metropolitan area fell consistently from 2008 through 2014. There have been many changes in the broader regional economy of the Midwest including increased air pollution control (some of which are under threat of federal regulatory rollbacks) and increasing reliance on renewables and natural gas in the electricity grid.
However, the costs from local emissions, while falling from 2008 to 2011, increased from 2011 to 2014. The upshot is that local air quality regulators must remain vigilant in limiting local emissions. The relative contribution that such discharges play in Pittsburgh’s air pollution levels is growing as the influence of regional sources recedes.
Looking forward, this research approach offers a valuable perspective in assessing large-scale economic development decisions. What will the ethane cracker plant’s net contribution to regional welfare be when its emissions are properly evaluated? How have ride-sharing services (and potential increased reliance on autonomous vehicles) affected air quality and environmentally adjusted measures of GDP? What are the consequences of continued, or increased, use of rail lines to transport hydrocarbons directly through Pittsburgh?
All of these are important questions best asked through a lens that includes environmental damages along with traditional economic indicators. We look forward to exploring them further.
Mr. Muller is an associate professor of Economics, Engineering, and Public Policy, and the Lester and Judith Lave Development Chair in Economics, Engineering, and Public Policy in the Tepper School of Business at Carnegie Mellon University. Mr. Tschofen is a doctoral student in the Engineering and Public Policy (EPP) program at CMU. Ms. Azevedo is an associate professor of Energy Resources Engineering and senior fellow at The Woods Institute for the Environment at Stanford University.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.