I opened an email the other day and found a note from a woman battling for her life. She is about to lose the arrows in her quiver.
In three short months, a five-year consent decree between UPMC and Highmark will expire and almost all cross-network collaboration will end.
That’s the way UPMC wants it. In fact, that’s what the boss, Mr. Win-At-All-Cost Jeffrey Romoff, demands.
As for Nancy? She is a little checkmark in the costs column of UPMC’s ledger.
Here is some of what Nancy wrote to me:
“I am being treated at the Hillman Cancer Center for a very rare cancer that Allegheny Health Network is not equipped to treat. However, because I have Highmark insurance, I am about to lose all my UPMC doctors. This is daunting. It is also interesting that I am participating in a research study at Hillman — they are going to lose me and the research data I might be able to provide — which is particularly troublesome in the case of rare diseases as there are not many patients to begin with. NO ONE WINS ... Please, it is important to keep this topic in front of people in the Tri-State area. We need the exceptional cancer care that Hillman provides. More articles, please. Time is running out!”
I’ve been told by many that Mr. Romoff, a businessman of formidable intellect and energy, operates from a central belief: What is good for UPMC is good for the region and beyond.
That makes some sense. UPMC is the biggest employer in Pennsylvania, the largest landowner in the region, the dominant health insurer and the premier medical provider. It is an economic engine, the giver of lifesaving and life-extending medicine, the force behind the promise of medical advances that could change the course of history. As a community, we certainly want UPMC to succeed. But what is the definition of success?
Being fiscally responsible doesn’t preclude being compassionate. Having a plan for market dominance doesn’t require destroying the competition. A worthy end doesn’t justify immoral means. And, we must question whether the end even is worthy if it entails hurting — perhaps killing — some of the people you’ve pledged to serve.
I’ve talked to economists and lawyers and businessmen: I’m cognizant of the value of vertical integration (the creation of a health insurance business to be paired with its medical provider business). I understand enough antitrust theory to know that the lawyers at the U.S. Justice Department see the local health care market as not particularly local. That is, the “market” extends far beyond Pittsburgh — to Cleveland, Baltimore, Eastern Pennsylvania and New York City. So, there’s theoretically plenty of competition for UPMC, even if it ends up being the last man standing in Western Pennsylvania. (I guess those antitrust lawyers don’t care about lengthy drives for sick people, difficult to access followup care and expensive out-of-town accommodations.)
I understand — boy, do I understand — that UPMC qualifies under existing law as a nonprofit and is, therefore, entitled to the lavish fringe benefits it enjoys: No property taxes are paid on any of UPMC’s vast hospital-related properties. And it can continue to solicit our charitable donations — from the Free Care Fund collections at elementary schools across the region to the millions in endowments from philanthropic foundations. I understand that, if our state legislators were to change the relevant rules, other worthy nonprofits could be caught in a mess.
What’s the answer?
The most direct way to get from here — the brink of calamity for more people than UPMC wants to acknowledge — to a place of equity in health care for all is for Mr. Romoff to have a change of heart. His mind is sharp and his spirit is driven. But, his heart? It needs some help.
I think he spends too much time in his throne-like chair (it really is, I’ve been told) in his perfectly appointed lair on the 64th floor of the U.S. Steel Tower. I think the clouds are blocking his view of the little people below. He should take a walk in his well-heeled shoes around some of the facilities he runs. Talk to a couple of patients getting chemo at Hillman.
Better yet, maybe Mr. Romoff could try to recollect what must have been a difficult time in his own life: When his first wife, Vivian, the mother of his two daughters, was diagnosed with terminal breast cancer. What would Vivian think of Nancy’s plight?
Karen Kane is a Post-Gazette editorial board member (kkane@post-gazette.com, 724 772-9180). Follow her on Twitter @KarenKanePG





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.