When “The Favourite” came out before Christmas, I was leery of what it might make of a favorite of mine. One of the great women of history, the indomitable Sarah Jennings Churchill, Duchess of Marlborough (1660-1745), has already suffered more than three centuries of bigoted disparagement.

So in preparation, I took down from my shelf a prized possession, a red morocco box containing Matthew Prior’s “Poems on Several Occasions” (London, 1709, first edition). The front endpaper is annotated and signed: “This was given me by Mr Maynwaring 1710 - - - - - S. Marlborough.”

The Duchess’ inscription in her copy of Matthew Prior’s “Poems on Several Occasions,” shown with its red protective case. It reads, “This book was given me by Mr Maynwaring - - - - S. Marlborough.” (Michael M. Santiago / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

It’s definitely Sarah’s handwriting. This was her book; she held it in her hands. Maynwaring was her political adviser and confidant. Prior was a major-minor poet who thought Sarah had cost him his government job. Perhaps the book was an attempt to placate her, although by 1710 she’d lost much of her power. But her signature has power still.

Thus inspired, I hurried to see “The Favourite,” starring Olivia Coleman, Rachel Weisz and Emma Stone, and I cheered when it got 10 Oscar nominations. I went again, twice. Director Yorgos Lanthimos has made a fine movie, gorgeous, witty, smart and bizarre even beyond the tale it tells of Sarah’s struggle of sex and status with her younger cousin, Abigail Hill, to be the reigning “favourite” of Queen Anne, who ruled England from 1702 to 1714.

Advertise with us

Anne is pretty inconspicuous beside the star trio of English queens: Elizabeth I, Victoria and Elizabeth II. But her reign was an important time in the history not just of England and Britain (she presided over the union with Scotland) but also America. And Anne actually ruled, heading all four branches of government.

You wouldn’t know that from “The Favourite,” which is a fascinating but avowedly fictional speculation on the three women’s private lives, with peripheral appearances by various political leaders (all male) and one of the two greatest British generals of all time. That’s Sarah’s husband, the Duke of Marlborough, who, like his only warrior peer, the Duke of Wellington, saved Europe from the French.

Sarah was the power behind Marlborough just as together they were the power (for a while) behind the queen. But while the movie briefly shows Sarah engaged in the business of administration, you’d never know there were major issues of governance, finance, law and religion at stake. Yes, it’s a beautiful movie and lots of fun. But what about that missing history?

Sarah

My first brush with the object of my fascination was in grad school, mainly through Jonathan Swift and Alexander Pope, favorite authors but both anti-Sarah. Swift had a day job as propagandist for Robert Harley, the Marlboroughs’ enemy. Pope wrote a satirical portrait of Sarah and had the effrontery to read it to her and say it was based on someone else.

Advertise with us

So after the movie, I turned to what I thought was its source, Ophelia Field’s similarly named “The Favourite: Sarah, Duchess of Marlborough” (2002, revised 2018; also issued as “Sarah Churchill, Duchess of Marlborough: The Queen’s Favourite”). It’s not a bodice-ripping tale of sexual competition, as the paperback cover might suggest, but a 550-page scholarly biography and a great read.

What a Herculean labor of documentary research! But the similar titles notwithstanding, it’s not the movie’s source. That script was first written by Deborah Davis in 1998, before the biography, and broadcast in 2008 as a BBC radio play, “Balance of Power.” Whether Ms. Davis’ radio script or eventual film script, co-written with Tony McNamara, benefited from Ms. Field’s huge labor, I don’t know.

Sarah Churchill, Duchess of Marlborough, circa 1700. (Charles Jervas)

Simply put, the life Ms. Field documents and interprets with great care shows Sarah to be as remarkable as her many doubters over a couple of centuries could never believe or admit. One pleasure is how often she quotes Sarah, who wasn’t a wit but was so frank and trenchant that she is witty in spite of her pragmatic nature. Dr. Johnson called her “a good hater.” The cliché is true: if Sarah had been a man, she would have been prime minister.

Her hold over Anne began early. At 13 she was given a place at court, where young women served as companions for young royals. Within a few years she was serving Anne in positions of ever greater authority. Sarah was beautiful, with commanding eyes — allies and enemies agreed on that. The movie and Ms. Weisz get that right, but you wouldn’t know that Sarah was five years older than Anne. This helps explain her hold over a young princess who was preternaturally shy, sickly, obese and at the mercy of political quicksands when her Catholic father, James II, was exiled by Parliament in the Glorious Revolution of 1688.

Sarah and Abigail weren’t the only objects of Anne’s adoration — there were others before, during and after. Women at court formed intense emotional relationships, documented in fervent letters. Whether these relations became physical remains an open question. Mr. Lanthimos’ movie says definitely yes — a plausible choice.

Advertise with us

While serving Anne, Sarah pursued John Churchill, an ambitious young soldier. It turned out to be a remarkable partnership. He did the fighting, switching loyalties as royal politics required and being rewarded with higher rank and noble titles. His 1704 victory over the French at Blenheim is said to have saved Europe. Sarah raised their children and ran their many houses, among them the magnificent Marlborough House in London and Blenheim, the biggest palace in England, a gift from Anne. Together with Sidney Godolphin they managed the queen and her government, Sarah’s intimacy with Anne being key, along with her political instincts.

Blenheim Palace, a gift from Queen Anne to the Marlboroughs, as seen in 2016. (Wikimedia Commons)

Sarah’s initial ascendancy over Anne went on for more than 20 years until the pressure of business, divergent political convictions, Anne’s determination to be a real queen and her irritation at being lectured at all started to split them apart. Then came Abigail Hill, a poor relation for whom Sarah had found a position at court and then promoted into the queen’s personal service. She soon wished she hadn’t.

Alternate facts

The movie fictionalizes a lot, of course. There’s no record of Abigail poisoning Sarah, though probably she wanted to. The drama about Anne waiting for a letter is far-fetched. Anne was smarter than the movie allows, and Abigail was no political innocent. More important are what the movie leaves out, including the business of political parties. The men you see weren’t just competing for power and money: there were deep-seated ideologies at play.

Whigs stood for limited monarchy and freedom of religion for dissenting Protestants. They were more likely to be the monied merchant class. Tories were more likely country landowners. Royalists, they defended the church by criminalizing dissent. The more radical Tories even wanted to bring back James, the exiled Catholic king.

Advertise with us

Anne owed her crown to that exile, which obliged her to the Whigs. But she was instinctively a high church royalist — a Tory. The political crisis in the movie is that Harley, a moderate pushed out by Sarah and the Whigs, joins the Tories just as Anne starts moving in that direction. His access to the queen is through Abigail, who is his relative, too.

The movie, for all its style, entertainment, great performances and welcome focus on the women who move the wheels of history, in content it rather resembles those biographies of Sarah that reduce her story to a drama of emotional needs and power plays.

Sarah was always a firm Whig, although she had to temper some opinions to keep Anne’s support. The main issue was taxation to support the war. But when the queen appointed a Tory ministry in 1710 to negotiate a peace, Harley was in and the Marlboroughs were out. That’s when the movie ends. You can’t tell when it begins, because events are jumbled together or omitted.

The war, called Queen Anne’s War over here, won England three Canadian provinces and started it on the way to empire. When Anne died, the Whigs brought in the German George I as king and stayed in power for most of the century. Whig ideals of political and religious freedom spread to the American colonies. Though Sarah was no radical — Marlborough property and a huge fortune temper radicalism — Ms. Field says the new world would have suited her.

Oh, and Sarah spotted a likely young man and in her will left him enough money to start a political career — William Pitt, future prime minister, leader of the next war with France when Fort Duquesne became Fort Pitt.

Afterlife

Advertise with us

In Ms. Field’s last chapter, she recounts the vicissitudes of Sarah’s reputation through 300 years, some two dozen biographies and a dogged tradition of misogyny and denigration. But the movie omits the equivalent, the quick look ahead you expect in even fictionalized history. So here’s my version of what happened to the movie’s major players.

• Abigail’s hunky husband was ennobled as Baron Masham in 1713, when Queen Anne packed the House of Lords to get the votes to ratify the peace. Abigail herself, now Baroness Masham, went over to the more radical Tories, then retired to private life and died in 1734.

• Queen Anne’s body gave up its struggles in 1714; she was just 49. She turned out to be the last of the Stuart monarchs..

• Harley was made Earl of Oxford in 1711. But when Abigail deserted him, the Queen sacked him. When she died, the Whigs imprisoned him in the Tower for two years. He died peacefully in 1724.

• When fired in 1711, as in the movie, the Marlboroughs went on a grand tour of the Europe he had saved, then returned, high in influence but never again in power. The Duke declined and died in 1722. War between England and France remained endemic for a century until that other greatest English general won the Battle of Waterloo.

Advertise with us

• And what of Sarah? She lived to 1745, almost 85, wielding influence, fighting with her children and grandchildren, writing and re-writing her memoirs and demanding the nation pay to finish Blenheim, a monument to the Duke’s generalship abroad and hers at home — but where the library for some reason doesn’t include her copy of Prior’s “Poems.”

Oh, and her great-great-(how many greats?)-grandson turned out to be Winston Churchill. When not in power, he wrote a biography of Marlborough in which he downplayed Sarah’s political skills because, you see, she was just a woman. Another of Sarah’s descendants was Diana, Princess of Wales, which means another descendant should one day be king.

As to the movie, for all its style, entertainment, great performances and welcome focus on the women who move the wheels of history, in content it rather resembles those biographies of Sarah that reduce her story to a drama of emotional needs and power plays. She was much more than that. Even in Ms. Field’s book, she remains untethered, a magnificent woman to occasion wonder.

Senior theater critic Christopher Rawson: cchr82@gmail.com.