They were the original Dumb and Dumber.
The team of Laurel and Hardy was born just as the silent film era was dying. In 1927, Al Jolson sang half a dozen songs and spoke a few lines of dialogue in “The Jazz Singer,” and audiences flocked to the sensational novelty even as the industry scrambled to embrace the new technology.
But Laurel and Hardy moved at their own stately pace, so before uttering a word they took a couple of years to crank out about 30 silent comedies. And even though silence was no longer golden audiences flocked to their films as well, because the characters were lovable and the films were flat-out hilarious.
And when they finally spoke it seemed as natural and inevitable as Ollie falling down a manhole and Stanley blinking in dimwitted bafflement at his friend’s sudden disappearance. Sound made them even more popular.
It took a long time to put the act together.
Oliver Hardy ran away from his Georgia home to join a minstrel troupe when he was only 8. He thrilled audiences with his singing, but was too homesick to remain. When he was 17, he opened the town’s first movie theater, and three years later, in 1913, headed south to find work in Jacksonville’s fledgling film industry. Because of his pleasantly rotund appearance — his body seemed to be composed entirely of circles — he was soon working regularly, notably as the comic heavy in a series starring Chaplin impersonator Billy West.
Read More
In 1918, he decided to try his luck in Hollywood, where one of the first films he made was “The Lucky Dog,” starring a brash young comic named Stan Laurel. They played a couple of scenes together, but it would be another decade before they became Laurel and Hardy.
Stan didn’t have to run away from home because he literally grew up in the theaters his father managed in the north of England. He loved watching the comedians best, and at 20, he struck comedy gold when he was hired by Fred Karno, an ex-circus acrobat who had dozens of companies touring his knockabout comedy sketches. Within months he was asked to tour America as the understudy to another talented newcomer, Charlie Chaplin. The two became close and often shared a room to save money.
Stan played other roles in the company but never the lead, because his roommate never missed a single performance. And four years later, when Charlie was lured to Hollywood to make films for Mack Sennett, the company promptly folded.
Something interesting began to happen.
The boys started getting dumber,
and the dumber they got the funnier they got.
Stan spent the next decade bouncing back and forth between vaudeville and Hollywood. But touring was exhausting and major screen stardom eluded him, so in 1926 he was pleased to take a full-time job working behind the scenes as a writer and director at the Hal Roach Studio.
By then, Roach had surpassed Mack Sennett as a comedy producer with popular series like the “Our Gang” comedies. But it irked him that he hadn’t developed a superstar comedian since Harold Lloyd left in 1923, following the sensational success of “Safety Last,” the iconic thrill comedy in which Harold scales a skyscraper and dangles from the hands of a clock high above city streets.
Roach started mixing and matching his players, but no combination clicked until he noticed that Laurel looked funny just standing next to another recent hire, Oliver Hardy. Roach and Leo McCarey, who would go on to make such classics as the Marx Brothers’ “Duck Soup” and Bing Crosby’s “Going My Way,” began working with the team.
Almost immediately, something interesting began to happen.
The boys started getting dumber, and the dumber they got the funnier they got.
Paradoxically, being dumb required that the stories develop in a rigorously logical manner.
In 1929’s “Big Business,” for example, the boys are selling Christmas trees door to door. After a couple of unsuccessful calls, they arrive at the home of the hotheaded Jimmy Finlayson, one of their best foils. Ollie ceremoniously presses the doorbell — he always executes such simple tasks with a flourish, a characteristic that Art Carney would adopt years later in “The Honeymooners.”
Fin opens the door, meerschaum in mouth and newspaper in hand. They’ve clearly interrupted his hour of relaxation. Giving them only a cursory glance, he shakes his head and shuts the door. But he has accidentally caught a branch of their tree in the jamb, so they are forced to ring again. Fin is understandably irked at being bothered a second time, so he snarls at them, shutting the door so abruptly that Stan doesn’t have time to pull the tree free. This makes it necessary for Ollie to ring a third time. But this time Stan is ready, and successfully yanks the tree away. Except that now his overcoat has gotten caught, necessitating a fourth ring. Stan frees the overcoat, but somehow the tree gets caught again...
This is excellent visual storytelling. Audiences understand and empathize with Fin’s frustration, while sympathizing with the boys’ innocent but intrusive attempt to ply their trade. The accidents appear perfectly credible, thanks to Stan’s smooth handling of the tree and his coat; it’s the kind of elegant comic choreography that’s virtually missing from today’s films and one of the reasons for the team’s continuing appeal.
But amusing as the sequence is, it’s simply been a setup for the exponential escalation that follows, which ends up with Fin destroying their car as they demolish his house. The rhythmic build of the action is matched by the ever-increasing glee of the participants.
And the audience. Children scream with laughter at this stuff, but it’s hard to hear them over the screams of the adults. Laurel and Hardy tap into some primal urges beneath our civilized veneer. Substitute robocalls, phone menus and spam for door-to-door salesmen and you’ll have an idea of why their films remain so curiously satisfying. For a few glorious minutes, life’s petty annoyances are transformed into joyful orgies of revenge.

Virtually alone among the great silent comedians, they made an effortless transition into sound. Their voices fit their characters perfectly, and sound allowed them to add a dimension of surreal verbal humor. In “Way Out West,” for example, Ollie is nervously trying to chat up a woman sandwiched between him and Stan in a stagecoach. “A lot of weather we’ve been having lately,” he says gamely, oblivious to her rising irritation as he continues with such conversational inanities.
Another corollary of their dumbness was that they became more childlike, even as Ollie persistently asserts his adult dignity with his courtly manners, fussy little mustache, and formal introduction of Stan as “my friend, Mr. Laurel.” But faced with any attractive woman, they become bashful and coy, and when they’re married, their wives are more like stern nannies than romantic partners. Their only important relationship is with each other, and in their pre-sexual world it seems only natural that we occasionally find them sleeping in the same bed.
Their innocence opened up rich veins of comedy for the team. In “Liberty,” another classic from 1929, they’re escaped convicts who take off their prison garb but accidentally put on each other’s pants. As they try to switch them back in various alleys or the back seats of cabs, they are continuously discovered by an assortment of cops, shocked matrons and burly men who glare at them suspiciously. It’s hard to imagine this lengthy sequence being inoffensive, much less funny, done by anyone else; in their hands it’s hilarious. “Liberty” is also one of the few films where it’s apparent that Stan’s mime skills are just as formidable as Chaplin’s.
There’s rich irony in the fact that Stan, who portrays the dumber of the two, was actually the brilliant comic mind behind the films. He always got at least twice Ollie’s salary, because he basically never left the studio, participating in the writing, directing and editing of every film.
But the duo didn’t realize the extent of their fame until they took a European vacation in 1932 and were mobbed everywhere. They were both pleased and dismayed when their “vacation” turned into an involuntary publicity junket.
When their film careers fizzled during the 1940s, they returned to Europe for several triumphant stage tours, one of which is the subject of the new biopic “Stan and Ollie,” a film that also deals with their occasionally messy private lives.
But it’s their public lives that are cause for celebration. Anyone who doubts that is invited to attend The Laurel and Hardy Laugh Challenge at the Regent Square Theater on Saturday, Jan. 26 at 2 p.m. David Newell (aka Mr. McFeeley from “Mister Rogers’ Neighborhood”) will join me in hosting an afternoon of some of their best films, including “Liberty” and “The Music Box,” their only Academy Award winner.
Anyone who makes it through without laughing gets a ticket refund, a jumbo tub of popcorn, and a surprise gift.
The theater is also running “Stan and Ollie.”
As to why their comedy still works, perhaps Hardy said it best:
“Once in a while someone will ask me where Stan and I dreamed up these characters we play in the movies. They seem to think that these two fellows aren’t like anyone else. I know they’re dumber than anyone else, but there are plenty of Laurels and Hardys in the world. Whenever I travel, I am still in the habit of sitting in the lobby — and I tell you I see many Laurels and Hardys. I used to see them in my mother’s hotel lobby when I was a kid: the dumb, dumb guy who never has anything bad happen to him — and the smart, smart guy who’s dumber than the dumb guy only he doesn’t know it.”
You’d have to be really dumb not to agree.
Dan Kamin trained Robert Downey Jr. for his Oscar-nominated performance in “Chaplin” and created Johnny Depp’s comedy routines for “Benny and Joon.” He performs worldwide in theaters and with symphony orchestras.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.