In the past, I’ve written about the debate surrounding free speech on college campuses. I termed the issue a “crisis” and wrote about it in apocalyptic terms. Like so many others, I was reading the stories about teachers being shouted down or lecturers being uninvited from campus. But, as it turns out, anecdotal evidence is not the most reliable basis for forming views on important issues.
According to a 2016 survey of college students by the nonpartisan Knight Foundation, 78 percent of respondents said they believe it is more important for colleges to “create an open learning environment where students are exposed to all types of speech and viewpoints.” Only 22 percent believed a college should restrict speech.
But as instructive as that kind of data may be, what news consumers usually get are anecdotes about college students run amok. In contemporary media, a story about a group disrupting a lecture or haranguing a speaker can have a lengthy shelf life. This, in turn, has created new material for pundits, most of them far-removed from college and many seemingly eager to wring their hands about the state of college campuses.
In fact, between May 2016 and November 2017, The New York Times published 24 articles and op-eds on America’s campus free speech crisis. Fox News, for its part, has an entire “Campus Craziness” section on its website.
The Knight Foundation survey did find a recent increase in the number of college students who reported a campus climate that prevents people from saying things they believe because others might find them offensive, from 54 percent in 2016 to 61 percent in 2017. Interestingly, however, it was left-leaning students who reported increased concern about speech-stifling campus climates whereas the concern of students from the political right diminished from 62 percent to 53 percent.
That data comes with an important caveat. The Knight Foundation has only studied the question of perceived campus climate for two years. It is a new data point that will warrant close attention in the years ahead.
On the question of “controversial speech,” which includes racist or sexist language that may be offensive but is permissible under the First Amendment, those who are college educated have a higher tolerance. A 2009 poll by UCLA showed that people with four years of college were less likely to support banning racist or sexist speech.
Similarly, a 2018 survey conducted by the nonpartisan nonprofit website The Conversation found that nearly 50 percent of college students report a greater tolerance for both liberal and conservative views after just one year of college.
Data about how often college students are punished for their speech is not readily available. But it is easy to find information about faculty members who have been punished for expressing unpopular views. Surprisingly, faculty members who espouse left-wing views are fired at higher rate than others.
Earlier this year, the Niskanen Center, a libertarian think tank, published a report by Jeffrey Adam Sachs, a political scientist at Acadia University in Nova Scotia. Mr. Sachs found that of the 26 faculty members fired in 2017 for political speech, 19 were fired for “liberal” speech, such as support of Black Lives Matter or criticizing President Donald Trump.
None of this is to suggest that the issues surrounding free speech are not serious. Many of the stories presented by the mainstream media focus on incidents involving expressions of right-wing perspectives, but the study by Mr. Sachs suggests whatever problem there is with free speech on campus spans the political spectrum, threatening both conservative and liberal speech.
People should not dismiss concerns about free speech on campus out-of-hand. Free speech is a fundamental human right and continued support for it will be critical. Understanding how students learn about free speech and come to regard it will be an important part of generating that support. Data should continue to be collected and discussions should still be had.
But when it comes to free speech on college campuses, the media, myself included, has often showcased the wildest, most anomalous stories. Instead, people should focus on the serious debates based on facts and without hysteria. A review of the available evidence suggests that colleges and college students remain committed, in the main, to free thought and free inquiry, and students would rather hear more views and more ideas, not fewer of them. We can expect that within the academy, robust discussions will continue.
So take a deep breath. The campus free speech crisis conjured up by politicians and professional pundits doesn’t seem genuine. But don’t let your guard down completely. At a time when attacks on free speech come from many corners, including the White House, continued vigilance is clearly in order.
Will Tomer is a Post-Gazette editorial page staffer: wtomer@post-gazette.com or Twitter @WillTomer





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.