“The past is never dead. It’s not even past.’’
I thought of that line from William Faulkner after watching Pennsylvania Attorney General Josh Shapiro present the grand jury report alleging abuse by 301 priests across the commonwealth. Sixteen of the more than 1,000 known child victims and their family members, all adults now, flanked Mr. Shapiro, holding hands, hugging and wiping away tears.
I then read most of the roughly 200 pages detailing the abuse by, and names of, 99 priests and religious brothers in the Pittsburgh Diocese. I’d met only one of these evil, twisted men, and our encounter was brief, but some of the names rang unholy bells. Some had been previously reported in the diocese’s 2007 settlement payment of $1.25 million to 32 people who said they were abused by 17 priests during a four-decade stretch ending in 1994. Others were publicly named when they’d been jailed. Or defrocked.
At least 43 of the 99 priests are dead, and Bishop David Zubik wrote in the Pittsburgh Catholic even before the report was released that “nearly 90 percent of all reported incidents of abuse in our own diocese occurred before 1990.’’
One reader emailed me Tuesday morning, “I’m sure it’s like Christmas morning at the PG, anxiously awaiting a flawed grand jury report against the Catholic church with hopes that your biased coverage will provide a much needed shot in the arm/readership boost to a dying publication.”
“Pray for the children,’’ I responded. “There will be a lot in those reports that will have us all hitting our knees in repulsion.’’
Read More
“Why no reports on public school teachers? Boy Scout leaders? Day care workers? ... As I said, more happened at Penn State than the Pittsburgh Diocese this decade ... But that doesn’t make the headlines. Please explain that to me.’’
Because this is the church. Because it is the place where we repent and seek forgiveness “for what I have done and what I have failed to do.’’ Because it’s not our job as Christians to protect the church’s brand; it’s our job to follow the teachings of Jesus Christ.
The report says that Father Richard J. Dorsch, a serial molester convicted in 1995 of sexually assaulting a 13-year-old boy in North Park in the summer of 1994, received $159,700 in “sustenance’’ payments from the diocese over the course of the next 14 years. One of Dorsch’s victims committed suicide in 2010, just a couple of months after the diocese announced it would stop paying for his mental health treatment.
The report also says that when Father Charles J. Chatt resigned as pastor of Our Lady of Loreto in Brookline in July 1992, following the first documented report of sexual abuse of children some 21 years before, “parishioners were told that he had resigned for health reasons and to allow him to better care for his aging parents.’’ He withdrew from ministry in January 2003 at Bishop Donald Wuerl’s request.
And so on. There’s far worse in the sickening litany of sins. They should enrage all good Catholics even more than they do those outside the church. If anything was clear Tuesday, it was that the victims were finally getting a measure of solace they had not received from an institution intended to provide exactly that — but was instead the source of their torment. The case for ending the statute of limitations for sexual crimes against children could not have been made any more profoundly.
When I’d read about all of the report I could stomach, this sinner walked up the hill to venerable St. Peter Church, my parish for almost three decades, for the 6:30 p.m. vigil Mass for the Feast of the Assumption.
Why am I still Catholic? I ask myself that, too. Communion is part of it. When I receive the Eucharist, I sense a connection to my departed parents and distant siblings, to ancestors I never met, and to fellow Catholics on every continent, all of us embracing the same liturgy. The church is also a place where I’ve encountered scenes of the most genuine and selfless love, like the time after an 8:30 a.m. Mass when a woman I didn’t know embraced an older Italian woman I revered and said through tears, “My sister died in Hungary,’’ prompting a long embrace and an easing of her grief that she could have gotten nowhere else.
After Mass Tuesday, a handful of us in the Society of St. Vincent DePaul met in the back pews. That’s a 185-year-old organization that began in France and is dedicated to the poor. The member who had the phone these past few weeks reported that we helped someone with a utility bill that kept her lights on, and another person with the rent. This Saturday a couple of us will go to the home of a woman who needs a twin-sized mattress for her bad back, and another person who could use a full mattress.
We do such things because they are what Christians do. When the meeting concluded, we said a prayer for the victims of the evil ones who hijacked our church, and also for the majority of priests who have done no wrong but now must forever atone for the heinous sins of their brethren.
Brian O’Neill: boneill@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1947 or Twitter @brotheroneill





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.