More than a dozen men pulled Zachariah Walker from his hospital bed after he suffered a gunshot wound in a shootout with white security guard Edgar Rice on the night of Aug. 13, 1911.
“I killed Rice in self-defense,” he pleaded with the crowd, according to the Montgomery Advertiser. “Don’t give me a crooked death because I ain’t white!”
His pleas were in vain. As a crowd of about 5,000 calmly looked on, the mob threw Walker onto a burning pile of straw and rail posts. Men stepped aside to let women and children get a better view. A witness claimed his screams could be heard half a mile away.
After Walker’s death, people collected “souvenirs” — parts of his body or fence posts from the grassy field where he died, The Coatesville Record reported.
The lynching of Zachariah Walker didn’t occur in Alabama or Georgia. It happened in Coatesville, Chester County, in Eastern Pennsylvania.
The Equal Justice Initiative, which previously compiled a list of 4,084 “racial terror lynchings” in the South, included deaths like Walker’s in a June report to show that racial violence knew no sectional boundaries.
Read More
“We want people to understand that racial terror lynchings were not exclusively Southern,” said deputy program manager Kiara Boone. “It was a national issue and one that should be talked about.”
Pennsylvania has three documented lynchings, including Walker’s. In December, the Post-Gazette’s Sean D. Hamill debunked a fourth lynching, erroneously reported to have occurred in Fayette County. Pennsylvania was not included in the latest Equal Justice Initiative study, which focused on eight non-Southern states with high lynching rates. Two neighboring states did make the list: West Virginia, which had 35, and Ohio, which had 15. In all, the report documented the killings of more than 300 black people in Oklahoma, Missouri, Illinois, West Virginia, Maryland, Kansas, Indiana and Ohio.
Numbers still elusive
But the definition of lynching varies. While the Equal Justice Initiative defines it as the extrajudicial killing of an African-American by two or more people who faced no legal consequences, other historians include the extrajudicial murders of whites or count killings in which perpetrators were charged and/or convicted.
“The extant historical sources are so spotty and so riddled by racial bias that definitive studies of lynching almost certainly cannot be written,” W. Fitzhugh Brundage, a historian at the University of North Carolina, wrote in his 1993 book “Lynching in the New South.”
“Lynching Beyond Dixie,” a 2013 book edited by Michael Pfeifer, professor of history at the City University of New York’s John Jay College of Criminal Justice, documented two Pennsylvania lynchings before Walker’s: Joseph Snyder in 1880 for the murder of a prominent local family in Bethlehem, Northampton County, and Richard Puryear for an 1894 murder in Stroudsburg, Monroe County.
Snyder was white and, after a mock trial, was hanged from a chestnut tree by a crowd of more than 100. Puryear, who was black, escaped from jail on the morning of March 16, 1894, and was chased until he was captured in a creek. He was taken to a nearby slaughterhouse and hanged from an oak tree, where his body stayed until 10 p.m., The New York Times reported. The rope was cut up and sold as a souvenir.
Although most lynchings involved people accused of crimes, many black men were killed for minor social transgressions.
In Millersburg, Ohio, a black man whose name remains unknown was hanged April 1, 1899, because “he had lingered about people’s doorsteps and annoyed them in various ways,” The New York Times reported. The newspaper said there were “supposed to be no Negroes” in Holmes County.
Walter Johnson’s 1912 lynching in Princeton, W.Va., had a more typical scenario: a black man accused of raping a white girl. He was in the custody of Mercer County deputies when a crowd of more than 5,000, led by the girl’s father, cut telephone lines and stormed the jail. County officials, who had already moved Johnson to try to protect him, told the crowd that he was innocent. It didn’t matter. They seized him, hanged him from a telephone pole and riddled his body with bullets.
Tim Konhaus, a history professor and coordinator of dual enrollment at Germanna Community College in Virginia, found in 2007 that the rate of lynchings between 1890 and 1900 was higher in West Virginia than in any Southern state. One of every 4,350 African-Americans met death at the hands of a lynch mob in West Virginia, and the rate continued to be as high or higher than in Southern states through the 1940s.

Creating a list of lynchings and lynching victims from newspaper accounts is difficult, said Ms. Boone of the Equal Justice Initiative. Newspapers aren’t always well-preserved and it isn’t always possible to search for terms such as “lynching.”
“There are lynchings that are only captured in oral history and in memory,” she said.
Even historians who have made a career studying racial violence have had difficulty in accurately identifying the number of lynchings.
“Hundreds of lynchings were accorded only a brief mention, particularly as they became routine affairs by the end of the [19th] century,” Leon Litwack said in his 1998 book, “Trouble in Mind.”
A database compiled by sociologists Stewart Tolnay of the University of Washington and E.M. Beck of the University of Georgia lists 3,916 victims of lynchings or suspected lynchings in 11 Southern states between 1882 and 1930. In 1995, they published a book, “A Festival of Violence,” using an early version of this database, and noted that they stopped counting after 1930 because, after the Great Depression, “lynchings could no longer be considered an essential part of” the Southern social fabric.
The Equal Justice Initiative’s 2015 report, however, documents 4,084 lynchings in 12 Southern states between 1877 and 1950.
Documenting the struggle
Lynchings, Ms. Boone said, were not acts of violence targeted at a specific person or a single family. They were, instead, messages “sent to the entire African-American community.”
The last lynching recorded in the U.S. was the 1981 murder of Michael Donald in Mobile, Ala. He was walking home on March 21, 1981, when a group of Ku Klux Klansmen forced him into a car at gunpoint. Hours later, they hanged his already-dead body from a tree.
His mother sued the United Klans of America and received a $7 million judgment, bankrupting the organization. Two men were convicted in the murder: Henry Hays was executed in 1997, and James Knowles is serving a life sentence in prison.
Ms. Boone said the study of lynching is just part of the Equal Justice Initiative’s goal of documenting the struggle of black Americans.
“If we don’t have that context, it’s hard to understand the struggles” of the civil rights movement and of African-Americans today, she said.
Alex Weidenhof: aweidenhof@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.