There is a very real danger that Obergefell v. Hodges, the 2015 Supreme Court case that legalized same-sex marriage, will be overruled as soon as Justice Anthony Kennedy leaves the bench — something that is likely to happen sooner rather than later.
The best, and perhaps only, way to prevent that eventuality is for both supporters and opponents of same-sex marriage to agree to an implicit cultural bargain to live and let live: The right agrees that same-sex marriage remains the law and the left agrees that sincere religious believers not be forced to participate in a practice that violates their consciences.
The danger to the Obergefell ruling is clear, and here’s how it plays out.
The decision was 5-4, with Justice Kennedy as the swing vote. Three opponents remain on the court.
Justice Neil Gorsuch, who was named by President Donald Trump to replace Justice Antonin Scalia, consciously molds himself around Scalia’s originalist jurisprudence, and Obergefell was the final step in a series of rulings in favor of gay rights that Scalia vociferously opposed. Justice Gorsuch almost certainly would be the fourth vote to overrule.
The fifth vote likely would be cast by Justice Kennedy’s successor, who probably would be picked from a list prepared for Mr. Trump during the presidential campaign. All of the persons on that list would be likely to vote against Obergefell. Hence, five votes.
Nevertheless, the overruling of Obergefell would not be a certainty. The rule of law and recognition of precedent, though in tatters, still have some authority.
Plus, any such action would create a legal nightmare. For one thing, married people cannot just be unmarried. For another, reversing Obergefell would reintroduce the intractable problem of non-same-sex-marriage states’ recognition of such marriages from other states.
Finally, there is no indication that Mr. Trump wants Obergefell overruled. Certainly, he has never said so publicly. And in this, Mr. Trump reflects his base.
What energized religious believers to support Mr. Trump, whom many found personally odious, was not the prospect of overturning the same-sex marriage decision, but the hope of protecting religious believers who oppose it. An obscure comment during oral argument in the Obergefell case that educational institutions that refuse to recognize same-sex marriage — in married student housing, for example — might lose their tax-exempt status convinced many voters that a Hillary Clinton Supreme Court would declare war on religious believers. That comment may have cost her the presidency.
And when it comes to protecting religious believers, Mr. Trump has delivered. Justice Gorsuch joined the recent Lutheran Trinity Church majority holding in which the court ruled, 7-2, that Missouri had to include a church in a playground-resurfacing grant program. This was a major expansion of the Free Exercise Clause of the First Amendment, which had not before required direct payment of money to churches.
For a self-styled originalist like Justice Gorsuch to join this expansion without the slightest attempt at historical justification, when narrower grounds were available, such as an equal-protection decision that would not have applied to the federal government, shows that protecting religious conscience now trumps even conservative interpretive principles.
This context creates the possibility for a wide-ranging, informal cultural compromise on the issue of same-sex marriage. The terms would be an acknowledgment by conservative religious leaders that same-sex marriage is here to stay and a commitment to leave the Obergefell decision alone. In return, supporters of same-sex marriage would call off the war of words against religious believers who, though they consider such marriages to be an affront to the institution of marriage created by God, are not arguing for some general right to discriminate against gay people as a group.
The place where this compromise could, in effect, be announced is the pending Masterpiece Cakeshop case, in which a baker has been cited for discrimination by the state of Colorado for refusing to provide a cake for a same-sex wedding. His right to refuse could be accepted.
Compromise is hard and our culture no longer seeks common ground. Why should believers on the religious right, who won the presidency and control of Congress, not press for everything they can get? Why should supporters of same-sex marriage, having won that right in court, now yield a right to discriminate against it?
As with all compromise, the answer is to promote peace and solidarity. Most religious believers already accept the fact of gay marriage, even its justice, though they personally do not feel they can participate in it. Most believers, including the baker in the Cakeshop case, are not asking for a general right to discriminate against gay people in the marketplace.
As for supporters of same-sex marriage, most also embrace religious freedom. The ACLU, for example, has often fought for the right of prisoners to follow religious dietary restrictions. But Americans are just not used to considering conservative Christians to be a minority group, who, in this rapidly secularizing culture, need and deserve protection for their beliefs.
How will this informal compromise manifest itself? In our words and in our hearts. We lower our voices and stop considering our fellow Americans to be our enemies.
`





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.