In Pennsylvania most of the money to pay our children’s school teachers and fund our local governments comes from taxes on real estate. Business owners pay property taxes on the value of their buildings and the land they sit on. So do homeowners and farmers. Many property owners in the state clamor for tax relief, especially senior citizens and those hoping to afford a home or stay in one that they already own. Surprisingly, the burden of funding our schools and local governments is not shared as broadly as possible, which means that fewer property owners bear a larger burden than necessary.

If I own a property worth a million dollars because it has a mansion on it, I pay property taxes on the full million dollars. But if I own property worth a million dollars because of natural gas in the ground, I only pay taxes on the value not attributable to the gas in the ground, which may be a small fraction of a million dollars. Why doesn’t the funding of local governments and schools, which comes primarily from property taxes, rest on the owners of all types of property, including the value of the natural gas in the ground?

In 2002 the Pennsylvania Supreme Court ruled that state law excludes oil and gas reserves from property taxes. In hindsight the ruling prevented local governments and schools from reaping substantial revenues as drilling in the Marcellus Shale boomed. In 2009, representatives of the General Assembly introduced House Bill 10, which would have allowed oil and gas to be subject to property taxes the same way that houses and land are taxed.

Since then, however, the public discussion of oil and gas policy has ignored property taxes. Those engaged in natural-gas policy issues have hotly debated a state tax on the value of natural gas extracted. Should the state have one? How much should it be? Should it replace the impact fee?

Advertise with us

These are important questions to consider but not to the exclusion of other options, such as taxing natural gas in the ground as property.

The revenue at stake is huge. Texas has a severance tax and also includes oil and gas reserves (once they are drilled) in property tax assessments. In 2011, the state’s severance taxes generated about $2.5 billion. Data from the Texas Education Agency indicate an oil and gas property tax base in 2011 of around $108 billion. Assuming an average local tax rate of 2 percent, oil and gas property taxes provide roughly $2.1 billion dollars in revenues to cities, counties and school districts.

No one likes more taxes, but taxing oil and gas as property makes sense for at least four reasons. First, the best taxes have low rates and are applied broadly. Taxing oil and gas in the ground would broaden the property tax base, allowing policy makers to lower rates while maintaining or perhaps even increasing revenue.

Second, it gives local governments and schools greater autonomy to respond to challenges and opportunities brought by natural gas drilling. Unlike the impact fee, which is collected and distributed by Harrisburg for prescribed purposes, locally elected leaders set property tax rates and decide how to spend the revenues.

Third, currently there is no direct way for Pennsylvania’s natural-gas wealth to improve local funding of public schools. Taxing gas in the ground as property would provide a direct channel for the state’s natural-resource wealth to expand the capabilities and opportunities of its youth.

Advertise with us

Lastly, roughly a third of the oil and gas in Pennsylvania is owned by people who live outside the county where the oil and gas is located and a tenth is owned by people living outside of the state. These owners benefit from drilling through royalties but do not directly contribute to paying for the costs associated with drilling such as the deterioration of roads or the salaries of additional local government staff needed for public service demands brought by drilling. Taxing oil and gas as property would ensure that nonlocal property owners who benefit from drilling help pay the costs associated with it.

Jeremy Weber is an assistant professor at the University of Pittsburgh’s Graduate School of Public and International Affairs (jgw99@pitt.edu).