Bruce Ledewitz argues persuasively that none of the Supreme Court justices are Originalists, a theory that the constitutional text must be interpreted according to its meaning at the time of its adoption (“Originalism is a mirage. Judges must exercise political judgment,” Nov. 3).

At a deeper level, we can show that even an attempt to be an Originalist is doomed. There is no way that any of us can fully understand the words written years ago.

We do not have the same world view, the same experiences, the same education or philosophical orientation of the founding fathers. We cannot sense the nuances that the writers would have been attuned to.

We have all experienced the difficulties that succeeding generations have understanding each other. When many generations have passed, true understanding becomes out of reach. It’s folly to imagine that anyone now is going to clearly understand documents written many generations ago.

Advertise with us

As Mr. Ledewitz states, Originalism is a cover for the exercise of political judgment. We can only hope that the court will at some point be honest with itself, and with the public, and take ownership of the truly disastrous decisions it has been making.

I’ll mention only two: The failure to allow reasonable gun control and the granting of non-constitutional immunity to the president. Chief Justice John Robert’s court, with its extensive misuse of its shadow docket, has betrayed the public, and failed to fulfill its duty to the country.

EUGENE STEVICK

Mt. Lebanon