In characterizing the Supreme Court’s rationale in Trump v. Anderson and Trump v. United States as “common law,” I believe Professor Bruce Ledewitz is too kind (“Originalism is a mirage. Judges must exercise political judgment,” Nov. 3).

The common law arose from custom in the English courts. It is judge-made law after the presentation of evidence and arguments in trial of a case or controversy to achieve what they believe is the most just and the fairest result, where there is no applicable statute. Moreover, it requires respect for the principle of stare decisis, i.e., precedent.

In the Colorado case (Anderson), the court all but ignored the elector clause of the Constitution that grants to states the power and duty to appoint (or not appoint) electors to elect the president.

In the immunity case, the court wrote a rule “for the ages” before evidence and argument could even be heard in a trial, and by the way, where the discussion of immunity should have started. By taking the case, and delaying its decision until literally the last minute, the court prevented a trial originally scheduled for March of 2024 and effectively prevented a trial from (so far) ever taking place.

Advertise with us

BRUCE WILDER

New Orleans, La.