Abby McCloskey makes an important point: God has no political party (“The Republican politics of Jesus and Jesus’s politics”, Nov. 6).

However, the details in her article misstate the evidence of how much our two major political parties diverge on questions of God and divine providence and how we are called to behave.

The most notorious example of that divergence was the Democratic National Convention’s excision of “God” from its party platform (complete with a chorus of boos in response to an amendment introduced to restore that status quo ante). But do religious words and touchstones have any bearing on a party’s political positions? The answer appears to be Yes, quite a bit.

For example, in a sadly misguided attempt at even-handedness, McCloskey writes “America’s two-party system draws arbitrary lines across orthodox Christianity ... [such as] one party’s priority of ending abortion and the other’s priority of helping the poor” — implying that Republicans prioritize pre-born babies while Democrats prioritize babies post-birth.

Advertise with us

Would that it were so. But as many studies (summarized by Arthur Brooks in his book “Who Really Cares?”) have shown, conservatives and Republicans not only care more than liberals and Democrats about pre-born babies, they also give more, in both time and money, to help the poor.

The relevant distinction that McCloskey may be trying to draw is that Democrats are more likely to demand government programs to feed the poor. But when Jesus said, “Render unto Caesar what is Caesar’s,” he did not say, “Then Caesar will love your neighbor so you don’t have to.”

That emphasis on individual — not government — responsibility springs from the Judeo-Christian Great Commandment, and is responsible for differences in party policies. Its corollary is that our rights, likewise, come from God, not from government.

People with a religious focus on God gravitate to a party with that focus. Those with a religious focus on government gravitate to the party of government.

No party can claim that God is on its side, but a party that tries to be on God’s side is likely to have different policies than one that does not. Religion plays an inherent role in policies and politics.

Advertise with us

JOHN KAUFMANN

Murrysville