In mailers and television commercials well-funded groups are suggesting that a no vote on the retention of three Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justices is necessary “to term limit the Supreme Court.” This is a fake argument. (I am writing as a former President Judge of the Superior Court.),

Unlike United States Supreme Court justices, who are appointed by the president, Pennsylvania Justices are elected by the people to ten-year terms. To continue serving, they must be reelected in a retention election. Unlike U.S. Supreme Court Justices who are appointed for life, all Pennsylvania justices and judges must retire at age 75.

The retention election provides accountability and has served Pennsylvania well by requiring every judge to seek voter approval to continue serving. Each voter should make the decision how to vote based on a jurist’s performance, not on the false argument of term limits.

Joseph A. Del Sole

Mt. Lebanon