Government is good at applying complicated solutions to simple problems. Recently, the FCC voted to reclassify the internet as a Title II service, the same way rotary phones were regulated a half-century ago. In doing so, it seeks to reinstitute a policy designed to make the internet “fast, fair, and open.” This net neutrality policy is considered a back-door approach to more heavily regulate the industry — regulations that aren’t needed because the marketplace is providing wireless, wireline and satellite competition.

The May 11 editorial, “Congress needs to make net neutrality a lasting policy,” supports reclassification and net neutrality. We argue that the implications of reclassification could go far beyond an open and free internet and threaten the network management that allows 9-1-1 calls or telehealth appointments to be prioritized over less urgent applications.

When net neutrality was first considered, proponents argued that if the internet wasn’t reclassified, it would come to a stop. Providers would block, throttle, and discriminate against traffic, and users would have to pay to visit every website. That never happened. If the federal government wants to prohibit blocking, throttling and discrimination, it should do so directly with legislation, rather than have it imposed by unelected bureaucrats.

This reclassification doesn’t solve any existing problems but would have lasting, negative impacts. The FCC’s split vote on the issue just exists to give government more control. As FCC Commissioner Brendan Carr said before his dissenting vote, the policy is “one of the greatest hoaxes in regulatory history.” We agree.

Advertise with us

Todd Eachus

President

Broadband Communications Association of Pennsylvania