There’s an old adage: “Build it, and they will come.” Much money has been lost by following that adage.

The editorial proposal for a “pop up” rail branch between the Waterworks Mall and Homewood has some credibility (“A brilliant plan to re-use the Brilliant Branch — for rail transit,” Apr. 25), since it has been proposed by Henry Posner III who has extensive experience in the rail business. I have no doubt that he can implement a functioning rail line.

But who would ride it? Where is the demand for such a line? Are the plutocrats of Fox Chapel clamoring to board a train at the Mall in order to change to a bus in Homewood? I doubt it.

This is as bizarre a rail connection as the Peduto-backed proposal, years ago, to connect Hazelwood with Lawrenceville just because a vacant right-of-way was available. Nor does your editorial contain any indication of a buy-in from Pittsburgh Regional Transit which would be vital.

Advertise with us

Orphan transit projects are seldom successful. Mr. Posner undoubtedly can muster private resources to finance the entire project himself at his own risk – and profit. I truly wish him luck, but County Executive Sara Innamorato should be wary about committing public funds for a project with such an uncertain outcome.

Carl I. Hammer

Squirrel Hill