Many readers were, no doubt, relieved that the Tiffany windows at a Philadelphia church were rescued from destruction “Salvaging Tiffany church windows in Philadelphia was a win, but not a windfall,” June 4). Many might be surprised that Tiffany windows were often threatened with destruction a century ago.
One such local window was mentioned in the sidebar (“Tiffany church windows in Pittsburgh”). At Shadyside Presbyterian’s 1890 opening, only one pictorial stained glass window graced the sanctuary. Tiffany Studios executed Correggio’s painting “Adoration of the Shepherds” in vivid opalescent glass. The balance of the windows were filled with “cathedral glass,” tinted, geometric patterned and intended for later replacement.
The window’s location on the south wall of the church is genius. At Christmastime, the sun’s path is at its most southerly. The glass depicting the Christ Child and his “swaddling clothes” gleams brilliantly and seems to illuminate the tender face of the Virgin Mary.
Replacement began around 1920, with donated memorial windows. These windows were furnished by the Gorham Company, a firm more associated with silver than stained glass. In the main, they depict scenes from the life and ministry of Jesus Christ using a more “conventional” technique. Tiffany windows were out of style and being removed from many homes and churches. Much of this disfavor can be attributed to the famed architect, Ralph Adams Cram, who considered them “triumphs of trickery … and hopelessly bad.”
There was serious talk of replacing Shadyside Church’s Tiffany Nativity window with one matching the new Gorham style. Mrs. Anne Darsie Thomson, a long-time and influential church member, led a group that saved the Tiffany.
Timothy C. Engleman
Saxonburg





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.