We are disappointed that the Post-Gazette editorial board penned a ringing endorsement of Move PGH and the Spin scooter deployment (“Pittsburgh Should Continue to Encourage Mobility Options,” Oct. 22) without reading the Move PGH pilot report they were referencing and Pittsburghers for Public Transit (PPT)’s response.

If they had, the board would have noted that in the past year, Spin e-scooters replaced more transit and walking trips (43.3%) than car trips (35.7%), leading to a net harm in carbon emissions and congestion. This is in line with recent international research demonstrating that shared e-scooters emit more CO2 than the transportation modes they replace.

Moreover, the editorial board would have read that the vast majority of Pittsburgh’s e-scooter trips are taken in Downtown, Oakland and Lawrenceville — communities with the most extensive public transit and bike infrastructure — by young men ages 18 to 24. The report’s own numbers suggest that shared e-scooters are not filling a significant unmet first-last mile transportation need. Only 6.9% of Spin trips are used in connection with transit.

Anyone who has used Pittsburgh’s pedestrian right-of-ways over the past year will have encountered Spin scooters splayed across sidewalks and curb cuts. For those of us who are in greatest need of transportation options, these scooters obstruct access instead of increasing it.

Advertise with us

The Post-Gazette, like the city’s Department of Mobility and Infrastructure and Move PGH, should consider reading the data before parroting Spin’s marketing spin.

Laura Chu Wiens

Pittsburghers for Public Transit