I thank Derek Woodward-Lehman for articulating the range of opinions about Queen Elizabeth, and noting that the most vocal negative responses have come from victims of her kingdom’s brutal imperialist legacy (“The late queen — angelic national mother or demonic imperial master?” Sept 21). It’s a needed analysis of imperialism that I, as a member of the Democratic Socialists of America, appreciate.

I especially appreciate the historical parallels he draws, noting that plenty of slaveholders, robber barons and fascists were personally kind and thoughtful, at least to those they were not exploiting or eradicating. I take issue with his phrasing of the two perspectives on Elizabeth as being in contradiction. In her role as a public figure, the benevolence that Queen Elizabeth displayed is not so much a contradiction to her empire’s bad acts as it is a matter of social function. After all, a monarch who bluntly and accurately articulates the violence of imperialism would hardly be a suitable figurehead.

Whatever positive values Queen Elizabeth personified — grace, dignity, humility — those are qualities that can be found among people of every social class, ethnicity and nationality.

However, the actions that are decried — giving honors to war criminals, allegedly bankrolling her son’s legal battle against sexual assault accusations (before finally stripping him of his title), and racist public sidelining against an addition to the family, among many more — those are actions that are specific, not to royals necessarily but certainly to the wider ruling classes whose main function in modern society is using public image to protect their own existence as a ruling class.

Advertise with us

A queen grips her scepter with unblemished white gloves in order to hide the blood-stained hands beneath.

Zach Michaels

Shadyside