In “How inequality serves the poor” (Aug. 19) John Tamny is factually correct as he elicits sympathy for the rich. True, mass-produced window air conditioners have made heat relief affordable to India’s poor while making someone rich. Should those poor be grateful for the income inequality created to achieve this noble act?

Let us examine an example closer to home. Walmart has provided America’s poor with a wide range of affordable goods. That is how the Waltons became the richest family in America.

In Oregon’s Rogue Valley where I lived in the 1990s, Walmart promised 400 new jobs in exchange for 10 years property tax relief. All Walmart non-management employees earned minimum wage: $4.25 an hour. All received federal, state, and/​or local welfare benefits. A Walmart employee in each district earned six figures being responsible for signing them up.

Within one year of opening their store, a dozen local businesses went bankrupt; over 300 jobs were eliminated. By then, Walmart had shed 200 employees. Those remaining did all the same work without increased compensation.

Advertise with us

Meanwhile, Walmart paid no local, state or federal taxes toward police departments protecting them from robbery, fire departments protecting them from fire, or maintaining roads necessary to transport goods to their stores. Who paid for employees’ welfare, police, fire protection and the roads?

Who compensated for lost property taxes for education? You, me, and Walmart’s underpaid employees.

Walmart was simply ensuring there were enough poor people to buy their “affordable” goods. Grateful for the inequality? I think not.

Thomas Crown

Allegheny Arsenal