In a recent essay (“A collision of economics and history,” July 17), David Shribman cast Pennsylvania as a key battleground in the fight for the global environment. On one side, in Shribman’s telling, are the people who care about the earth, brimming with smart ideas to save the globe. On the other are the ignorant forces thwarting those efforts, including organized labor members, who foolishly see their jobs and way of life at stake.
One of those so-called good ideas is the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative. RGGI, as it is known, charges a price penalty and places an ever-shrinking limit on the carbon produced by member states as they generate electricity with fossil fuels. Shribman noted an “unusual coalition of Republicans and labor unions” who joined forces against Gov. Tom Wolf’s unilateral effort to join RGGI. (I write as one of those union members, as business manager of Iron Workers Union Local No. 3.)
How much carbon will be kept out of the atmosphere if Pennsylvania joins RGGI and helps save the planet? Virtually none, according to the analysis from Wolf’s own Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection. That’s because carbon-based generation will increase in other non-RGGI states as it is reduced in Pennsylvania by the RGGI price penalties.
Yet those RGGI penalties will raise the cost of wholesale electricity in Pennsylvania by almost 20% by 2030, according to the DEP analysis.
So yes, organized labor has opposed a so-called environmental policy that doesn’t reduce carbon but raises electricity prices and costs jobs.
Energy issues are complex. If we make the wrong decisions, they can lead us down a path we do not want to go. Just ask the Germans, who thought they were helping the environment by shutting down their nuclear plants. Now they burn coal and trees to generate electricity, and they may not have enough energy to heat their homes this winter.
Greg Bernarding
Board member of Pittsburgh Works Together





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.