No, Rachel Carson didn’t get it wrong (“Rachel Carson was also wrong,” Letters, June 26). Her book “Silent Spring” issued a warning of the consequences of the indiscriminate use of pesticides. The use of DDT for mosquito control in sub-Saharan Africa is certainly not an indiscriminant use.
For example, when a mosquito-borne strain that had previously been eliminated returned to South Africa, it was resistant to the pyrethroid insecticides that had replaced DDT. The resulting increase in malaria cases and deaths was epidemic. South Africa had to fall back on DDT, and still uses it in areas where other chemicals might fail.
The consequences of the carefully controlled use of DDT are certainly preferable to letting people die from malaria.
Anthony Gaglierd
Munhall
The writer was environmental health administrator of the Allegheny County
Health Department





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.