The movement of Joe Biden toward the political center in his first State of the Union address was much noted by commentators at the time but swiftly eclipsed by the war being waged against the people of Ukraine.
But the president's shift is worth revisiting, and it relates to the war.
It is also good news for the country and maybe even a way to save the Democratic Party from itself. And that matters more than it might because it is not at all clear that the Republicans can be saved from themselves.
This is not just a matter of Mr. Biden trimming his sails, however. Centrism is both a governing style and a body of values that are the mark of several successful presidencies: I am thinking of Harry Truman, Dwight Eisenhower and Bill Clinton, in particular.
Centrism is not the same as meeting in the middle, or “the middle of the road,” where many accidents occur.
Centrism is a way of doing politics. Its modern charter was drafted in 1949 by Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr. in a book called “The Vital Center.” It was written as a defense of democracy itself in what was often called “the age of anxiety,” and as a reaction to the failure of the left and right — both the extreme right and left then present in Europe and the softer but impractical right and left in American politics.
Read More
The great cause of centrism is to defend liberty and democracy itself (free speech and inquiry) against collectivists and fascists.
It is the path of measured and responsible government policy as opposed to political paranoia (masquerading as populism) and condescension (masquerading as compassion), and thus highly relevant to this moment in our common national lives.
Let’s get more specific. Here are some of the key elements of democratic centrism:
- Progressive capitalism:
Centrists believe in capitalism and not in socializing every problem or even every common good. They acknowledge that centralization of power usually happens at the expense of “small platoons” and individuals. Indeed, even of families. But they are not believers in unregulated capitalism, or corporations that are so large they cannot be allowed to fail and are, in some sense, sovereign entities within our sovereign nation.
Capitalism creates wealth, but it needs moral guidance from culture and society, which is ultimately expressed by government.
Hence, centrists defend the free market but also minimum wage laws; regulation of food and drugs; Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid.
- Enough justice:
A guiding precept of centrism might come from theologian Reinhold Niebuhr, who instructed Schlesinger in what he called “Christian realism”: Government cannot create justice, but it can prevent too much injustice.
Social Security sought to end elder poverty (and gradually expanded) but not to redistribute wealth.
Applying this sort of limited entitlement to something like the problem of college loan debt might lead a president, or a party, to ban excessive interest rates but not cancel all student loan debt. Or, to move to assure that public higher education is affordable but not necessarily free.
So, centrism is anti-Utopian, as it is anti-reactionary.
- Building alliances:
Centrism, as articulated by Schlesinger, and others like John F. Kennedy, also embraced internationalism and the notion that foreign entanglements are, in fact, unavoidable, and so foreign partnerships and friendships are desirable. Both the left and the right tend to be isolationist.
- Government intervention:
Centrism turns to government as a last and not a first resort. But when society and culture are too out of balance to solve a problem — like poor drinking water, or unsafe cars or the high cost of medical treatment — government may have to referee or even intercede.
There may be other areas where lack of regulation, laissez faire, is the better road to tolerance and liberty — like academic freedom and curriculum in local schools.
There is another, more overtly political, form of centrism, which I would call democratic centrism: It is characterized by an orientation toward working class people — one that is pro-union, frankly for managed and protective trade policies, and is not embarrassed to care about the poor and want to make them workers.
But it is democratic centrism that we really need because, first, it focuses on defending democracy itself and, second, it is a pathway to modest, achievable progress rather than “the great society.” It’s about small-bore change that we can measure and that we can achieve and sustain, rather than remaking the country or human nature itself. It's about being better rather than returning us to a state of innocence or a country that never was.
There aren’t many centrist politicians around these days. Rob Portman is one. Tom Ridge and Mitch Daniels were centrists. So was Daniel Patrick Moynihan, who called himself an “Al Smith Democrat.” But embracing centrism may let Joe Biden be Biden: If we care about cities, and poor folk in cities, we train cops. We don’t de-fund them
When the American left tells us we can’t let a war deter us from working with Mr. Putin on climate change and the right tells us the war is none of our affair, we can see that we need democratic centrism, or realism.
When we worry more about gender norms and names than genocide, it is clear we need re-centering.
Keith C. Burris is the former editor, vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (burriscolumn@gmail.com).






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.