I want to say something guaranteed to enrage both Trump defenders and pursuers: There is more at stake in the possible impeachment of President Donald Trump than Donald Trump himself. And I wish more of our leaders could see this and articulate it.

Like what? What is more important than removing a president who upsets so many people and seems to so many Americans so very unpresidential?

Well, several things: Due process of law is more important. The separation of powers is more important. The presidency, as an institution, and the president, as head of the executive branch, are more important. The people's faith in our democratic and legal institutions and procedures is more important.

Faith. The democratic faith is the essential thing. And due process — the concept upon which Western civilization depends.

Advertise with us

But no one at the center of our current impeachment drama is acting that way — not the president or his defenders, and certainly not Jerry Nadler, or Adam Schiff, or Nancy Pelosi.

Ms. Pelosi went off on a reporter the other day who asked if she hated the president. Maybe she had a right. But her answer documented all the president's policy failures and made palpably clear her profound disdain for the man, if not her hate. She then said that all of her objections to Donald Trump are about the election. No, she said, this impeachment is about the Constitution. But she made not one constitutional argument to impeach.

The president, to be sure, has violated norms of our politics, implicit and explicit, stylistic and substantive. But what law?

To echo George Washington University law professor Jonathan Turley, a liberal Democrat who voted against Mr. Trump and testified before the House Judiciary Committee last week: One may be deeply troubled by those violations, as people across the political spectrum are (conservatives have been particularly aggrieved by the president's behavior), and still fail to see a constitutional or legal violation. That does not mean there isn't one, as Mr. Turley said, but that the case has not been made.

An impeachment process that is slapdash, in which an evidentiary trail has not been blazed, does harm to more than norms. It harms the system itself.

Advertise with us

Impeachment without due process does grave damage to the country — greater damage than all the president's insults and misspelled, reckless tweets.

Mr. Nadler began the hearing with a long indictment of the president. It was as if a judge began a trial with a verdict. That should trouble everyone.

Yet, without anything extralegal having been established, without anything but policy confusion and vanity being established, we have two draft articles of impeachment: abuse of power and obstruction of Congress. No bribery and no extortion, presumably because not even a one-sided case for either could be convincingly made.

Is abuse of power impeachable? If two-thirds of the Senate says so. But modern presidents have generally abused power. And there is no evidence that that many senators are ready to cite abuse of power as impeachable.

There were heroes in the House Intelligence Committee hearings. Fiona Hill was perhaps the most prominent one. We got a glimpse of a true public servant — someone taking care of the government on behalf of the republic and the things for which it stands. But her indictment of the president and his men was for carelessness, not high crimes or low ones.

Advertise with us

Mr. Nadler's Judiciary Committee hearings? No heroes. Barely a process. Instead, an unseemly and unworthy (of the House) rush to judgment.

So we are back to the question: Why are we doing this? Why impeach when the case is really political and we are already deep into the presidential election?

Because the Trump derangement really is a mania, and it holds otherwise reasonable and rational people (the speaker is one, and she is backed by roughly half the voters) in its grip.

And maybe a few dime-store Machiavellians also think impeachment will help the eventual Democratic nominee defeat Mr. Trump. If so, it begins to look like they have badly miscalculated.

But if the president's enemies have failed to put the country and the presidency before their wrath, so has the president failed to put both before his ego and his pique. He, too, has failed to take care — profoundly so.

Advertise with us

The actual Machiavelli wrote that the patriot and the statesman had to love “the city” more than he loved not only his own interests, but justice and the good. That's worth pondering. Think of Lincoln and his one clear vision: preserve the union. And then think of the public men and women of today. Where are the guardians of our republic?

The last presidents who really had a sense of the presidency as a constitutional office — beyond themselves and their own tenure — were Gerald Ford and before him Harry S. Truman. The presidency has been more and more imperial and abusive of power in every other president since Franklin Roosevelt.

The last congressional guardian was Sam Ervin, the North Carolina senator and former judge who led the Senate's investigation of Joseph McCarthy and, 20 years later, Richard Nixon. In both cases, the evidence was developed carefully and slowly, and each step was designed to preserve, and enhance, public confidence in our institutions and our law. The Democratic faith, and not the alleged bad guy, was the chief concern and due process was held sacred.

Ervin strove to take care of our system. No one in Congress has emerged as equal to him, or even to emulate him, in the Trump impeachment melodrama.

Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette, and vice president and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).

Advertise with us