Another shooting at another place of worship. A woman dead. A 19-year old boy the shooter, armed with an assault weapon. The only reason more people did not die is that his gun jammed.
This was followed swiftly by another campus shooting. This one at the University of North Carolina Charlotte. Six students were shot, two were killed. One, Riley Howell, was a hero. He charged the gunman and saved lives by sacrificing his.
And now we shrug. We have been desensitized, hardened.
And worse. We seem to have lost faith in our capacity to act, to change things, to make a difference.
Our leaders are hapless and we are hopeless in the face of gun violence and hate.
There are commonsense things we can do: assault weapon buy-backs; a tougher and comprehensive national background check system; a unified national waiting period; a no-fly equivalent for people with a history of poor mental health or spousal abuse; better mental health screening and care, including institutional care; incentives for so-called “smart guns.”
None of these steps would make the problem of gun violence go away. All would help. Why on earth wouldn’t we try?
There is a strange passivity toward this problem, which, perhaps, is now abating somewhat. (There are new members of the House of Representatives ready to take on the National Rifle Association, and few are of the hard left).
Children gunned down in their schools? Why, as a society, would we not tackle this? Have we lost all self-respect?
We have addressed unsafe cars and cancer and AIDS.
We even, as one father of a young woman killed in her school in Parkland, Fla., says repeatedly, made the airports and airlines safe from terrorists.
Why do we treat gun violence as insurmountable?
How to make schools safer? It’s not rocket science. Start with trained, armed guards, safe rooms that are impenetrable (movie stars have them), and solid security systems and procedures.
Hate crimes, hate speech, and hate thought is a much tougher nut to crack.
The ground of hate crime is (at least) two-fold: Racial and religious hate ideology and the internet (primarily social media). Sites that allow crazies to propagate and incite must be held accountable.
But we still need free speech. The way to combat hate speech is ultimately with thoughtful and charitable speech.
And by not dumbing down free speech by chilling all controversial speech or by labeling all non-PC speech as bigotry.
Much criticism of Israel or Islam may be unsubtle or ahistorical or simply wrongheaded. That does not make it anti-Semitic, Islamophobic, or hate speech.
To criticize the current prime minister of Israel is not the same as being anti-Semitic.
And most mass murderers are, on some, or several, levels, mentally ill. They are not simply, or strictly, political zealots. They may be fed by zealots. But not every political zealot (I have known a few) is an assassin.
We need to rebuild our social norms, and the practical, concrete structures of tolerance, civility and love.
We also need to keep guns out of the hands of very specific kinds of people and get mentally ill people the help they need — including long term hospitalization.
One problem (racial and religious hate) is a macro problem, the other problem (gun violence) is complex but a practical matter, and there are remedies.
The justification for addressing the gun violence problem is limiting rights. That’s right, I said it: limiting rights.
We have been expanding individual rights for over 200 years. We now need to expand our duties.
The Second Amendment is not absolute. Even the First is not. (The deeper and broader the better. But even free speech is not absolute — as with snuff films or video by a man recording his own mass killings.)
The First Amendment is about thought and ideas, just as the Second is about self defense. And the lines are not that hard to draw.
The line between Henry Miller and child pornography is discernible.
The line between the right to defend yourself in your home and the right to own weapons of war, including a tank or a bazooka or a bomb, is clear.
The right to freedom of religion does not include the right of a cult to kidnap people or engage in human sacrifice.
The country now needs a Bill of Responsibilities. We have expanded rights to more and more types of people (as if people came in types) and even to objects. And we have extended the number of rights — all the way down to the right not to be offended or made uncomfortable.
How about some balance?
How about a Bill of Obligations?
What do we all owe the country? Two years of universal service? One?
What do we owe our towns and states and neighbors? A pledge to buy products made locally and by our friends and fellow citizens?
What do we owe the people who grow our food?
Or our parents and their memories?
Or our children?
Or Mother Earth?
Gun owners and hunting enthusiasts, in particular, have a very special responsibility, corresponding to their right, to help keep our children safe in their schools.
I think we need a values revival in America — a rediscovery of human frailty and modesty via the rediscovery of God. We need a renewed faith in Christianity, Islam, Judaism and classical humanism over material wealth and success.
Or maybe it works the other way around. It is possible that an enunciated list of obligations might lead us back to the eternal verities, perhaps even the Creator, by leading us away from ourselves.
Keith C. Burris is executive editor of the Post-Gazette and editorial director of Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.