When he was dying Charles A. Lindbergh pulled together much of what he had been writing over the past 20-odd years — on technology, on environmentalism and natural preservation, on aeronautics — and he asked his publisher, William Jovanovich, to organize it into a book. The result was a tome called “Autobiography of Values.”
Lindbergh was a “great man,” who fell from public favor, for some very good reasons, but also, perhaps (he believed anyway), because he was misunderstood. He wanted to explain himself by exploring his core and animating beliefs.
It’s a largely undiscovered book with a great title.
I think we need more probing into values today: Why do we think what we think about CNN, Beto or the mess in Virginia? What lies below our knee-jerk politics, as journalists, as citizens, as politicians?
What do our would-be leaders really believe?
I don’t mean their positions on political issues and legislation, but what are the value systems of the various 2020 presidential candidates now emerging?
Read More
And what are the values of many of the pundits who opine on the politicians?
If you asked Joe Biden what is the one political, personal or moral value that best summarizes and defines him what would he say?
What would Kamala Harris or Cory Booker say?
At the moment most of the candidates are liberal senators who pass all or most of the the litmus tests — on Donald Trump, on Betsy DeVos, on immigration, on health care, on taxing the rich, on free college, on a Green New Deal.
But what do they believe? What are their animating principles? Their core values?
One of things that that sets him apart is that Sen. Sherrod Brown of Ohio is trying to define himself with an appeal on this credal level. His core value? The dignity of work, across all social and economic boundaries.
The press should certainly cover the records and the positions of all the candidates, including the president. But the country needs to know that there is more to our leaders than posturing and polling — if and when there actually is more.
For we all need to do more than react.

For most of my life it has been the political right that has been reactionary. From the time of Franklin Roosevelt to Ronald Reagan, the right was reacting to FDR and communism.
Today it is the left that is reactionary. That is, much of its politics is rooted not in principles and ideas but in identities and postures. And just as the right was angry for that 35-year period, the left is incredible angry today.
What cured the anger of the right was power, beginning with Reagan. But, also, some animating ideas.
I think Donald Trump has a huge political advantage in that he has a value structure. He is weak on policy details and understanding of the mechanics of government. But he has his “America first” values, which inform his policies, be they on NATO, foreign wars, free trade or immigration.
Democrats need more than “Trump is evil” if they are to beat the president on the values level.
I’d like to see the old Edward R. Murrow radio show “This I Believe” revived. On that show, both the famous and not-so-famous were given five minutes to explain their values. Not their religious faith and not their positions on the political issues of the day, but what values guided them in public and private life.
I’d like to see every candidate for president submit to this five-minute test.
What is your personal guiding star? Is it honesty? Is it loyalty? Is it courage?
In public matters is it the First Amendment? Personal freedom? Is it justice as fairness?
The animating idea exciting many Democrats today is socialism — democratic socialism. No one should be too rich and the wealth of society should be more evenly distributed. Is that a winning value, even in the hands of an imperfect tribune? I am not sure. But it is a value.
We have to engage in a values discussion to pull ourselves up above the level of reaction.
Editorial writers, for example, should constantly engage in a kind of examination of conscience: Do we favor this proposal as self-evidently good for any reason other than it seems to us self-evidently good?

I have written in this space of what I take to be classical liberalism and classical conservatism, and also of some of my own teachers and mentors, like John W. Chapman of the University of Pittsburgh, who taught me that to write is to think. All writing should be a thought exercise. Writing that merely reacts or strings together cliches is, to borrow from Truman Capote, not writing but typing.
Of the three modern political philosophers who have most influenced me — Reinhold Niebuhr, Hannah Arendt and Michael Oakeshott — I see little in common, save for one thing: limits. They all believed that there are limits to what we can know and understand and limits to what we can accomplish, though Niebuhr and Arendt say this should not diminish or discourage our best efforts. For Oakeshott, we can still master great disciplines and craft, including the crafts of music, government, history and philosophy. And we can still form bonds of association and the most precious bond of all — friendship.
We need the tragic sense of life and the courage to act anyway.
For me, in private life, the great values are curiosity, kindness and hard work. “Kindness,” said the Dalai Lama, “is my religion.”
In public life: tradition, civility and skepticism.
And, leaving people alone to work out their own destinies. The singular soul should be inviolate. As I grow old, I find myself very sure of what I do not believe in: Experts, mobs, conventional wisdom, fixing people, answers and solutions.
“Man’s capacity for justice,” said Niebuhr, “makes democracy possible, but man’s inclination to injustice makes democracy necessary.”
That is an autobiography of values in one line.
Keith C. Burris is editor and vice president of the Post-Gazette, and editorial director for Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.