I met him only once.

It was 1988 and he was the vice president, running for president.

The meeting was on the campus of the University of Toledo. And I was in the company of the publisher and editor-in-chief of this newspaper, John Robinson Block, and a then-colleague named John Nichols, now of The Nation magazine. Mr. Bush was seeking The Blade’s presidential endorsement.

We met the vice president in a conference room on campus before a speech. I remember, for some reason, that parking was scarce and we had to park far away, semi-legally on the side of a semi-hill.

Advertise with us

But what I remember best is that I came away from that meeting thinking: “Was I ever wrong about that guy. We have all gotten him wrong.”

Mr. Bush was nothing like what I expected him to be. I expected a sort of Americanized Bertie Wooster, a “tennis anyone?” uber-preppy type. But there was steel in this guy. When he looked at you and gave you a very direct answer, it was with a hard, cold eye.

Read More

This was not the man the press later ridiculed for his syntax, and his lack of knowledge about supermarket checkout lines, or his response to a waitress in a New Hampshire diner who asked him if he wanted more coffee — “just a splash.”

This was a substantial guy and a battle-scarred, determined, professional politician.

Interestingly, I do not recall any “issue” we talked about. We asked him about the most challenging time in his life. It was not World War II, but the loss of his daughter Robin. He talked about that for quite a while, and it was moving because he did not speak gushingly but almost clinically about her illness and death and how it changed him.

Advertise with us

And I recall that he told us he would retire to Texas, not Maine, when his career ended.

Finally, I remember that we had an African exchange student, an intern, with us. He did not come into the meeting but waited in the anteroom, just to meet the veep. Memory is strange. I cannot summon the young man’s name or which country he was from (it was tiny), but I do recall that Mr. Bush really took his time with that young fellow who, of course, could not even vote for him. And he knew a lot about his country. He’d been there.

That guy, the George Herbert Walker Bush I met that day, never appeared in the national media in his time. The country never really knew who he was or what made him tick — until last week.

And I think this is how it is. We never get our national figures right in real time.

They say journalism is the first draft of history. And it is — but it is a very rough draft. And sometimes it is extremely unjust.

Advertise with us

I worked, for a year before going to grad school at Pitt, for Sen. Eugene McCarthy, as basically a glorified gofer. I knew him well until the end of his life and helped him organize his last major book. He was not the caricature the D.C. press made of him. He was not an aloof intellectual but a warm-blooded Irish pol who could work a barroom. He was not a flaky poet but a nature poet with the big frame and massive hands of the farmer and baseball and hockey player he’d been.

We got him wrong. We get all of these guys wrong. And the only antidote is history and a dash (splash?) of humility. Watching George W. Bush eulogize his father, I could not help but think: “We got him wrong, too.” “W” wasn’t the Devil and Barack Obama wasn’t Jesus. “W” wasn’t Alfred E. Neuman and Mr. Obama was not Lincoln.

We need history. And third and fourth drafts of it too. Instant history isn’t history. All that Theodore H. White did was concretize the mistakes.

Think of how long it took for President Truman, or President Eisenhower, to get a worthy biography, one that painted an accurate picture of the man and his place in our past. Forty years.

Robert Frost scholars will tell you that the first wave of biographers was worshipful, the second hateful and the third got him about right.

Advertise with us

We need time and perspective to see clearly.

For by getting the players wrong we often get the story wrong. Did the New Deal really end the Great Depression? Has Donald Trump done more for the black man, by reducing unemployment, than the War on Poverty did? GHWB hated debates. He said they had nothing to do with governing. Was he right? (I think so.) It takes time to grapple with such questions.

We have enough distance now from John F. Kennedy to begin to assess his presidency more soberly. He wasn’t a demigod. He wasn’t a sociopath. Maybe what he mostly brought to us was style and wit. But maybe that was enough.

Of the first President Bush, it was said in his time: Decent, sure. Competent, sure. But he’s “transitional.” A caretaker. Guys like him don’t change the scenery or the narrative.

Almost the exact same thing was said of Gerald Ford.

Advertise with us

What we could not see then was that decency and competence are enough. Indeed, they are the rarest commodities of all.

These days the country craves decency and competence on every front. The need to celebrate genuine competence is why we love Bill Gates. The craving for decency is why we have fallen in love again with Fred Rogers. This past week of grieving for a man was really the expression of a vast and deep longing for the qualities we now see that we so desperately lack.

Decency and competence. Now, a quarter of a century after the end of his presidency, we finally grasp the significance of George Herbert Walker Bush.

Keith C. Burris is editor and vice president of the Post-Gazette, and editorial director for Block Newspapers (kburris@post-gazette.com).