Post-Gazette editorials and columns have hit the Allegheny County Jail hard since I came to Pittsburgh 16 months ago. Prisons, jails, and the criminal justice system have, more than any other issues, defined my work since, as a young reporter more than 25 years ago, I spent two weeks in a medium-security prison opening in Oshkosh, Wis., where I landed my first newspaper job.

Since then, I’ve been in more than 60 prisons and jails — including all 30 Michigan state prisons while at the Detroit Free Press. I’ve talked to hundreds of prisoners and ex-prisoners, and hundreds of more who were in danger of becoming a statistic in the machinations of mass incarceration.

Even before I arrived, I knew the Allegheny County Jail had problems -- because all jails have problems. All of them serve as their county’s largest mental health centers. All are crowded with people who don’t belong there. All are overwhelmed by drug addiction and treatment needs they aren’t equipped, or designed, to meet.

But I didn’t come to Pittsburgh to investigate another inhumane jail, or repeat the Pulitzer run I had two years before by exposing needless deaths in another county jail in East Texas. Instead, I planned to step back from some of the hard-knock issues that had consumed my professional and personal life.

Advertise with us

Getting pulled in

Two or three weeks after I got here, however, the Allegheny County Jail pulled me in. It quickly became apparent that its problems really were worse than those of most other jails, and the media were largely ignoring them.

Its death rate was among the nation’s highest, despite the specious miscalculations of Warden Orlando Harper. The number of prisoners on probation detainers was scandalously high. The warden’s relations with his employees, the community, and the Jail Oversight Board were strained to the point of dysfunction. The jail was violating the voter-approved referendum limiting the use of solitary confinement, as well as its own housing policies. It had cost county taxpayers millions of dollars in lawsuits.

Mr. Harper certainly did not create all of the jail’s problems. He has no say, for example, on how local judges use probation detainers; he can’t control who goes to jail and who doesn’t.

Still, festering problems won’t improve as long as Mr. Harper runs the jail. He’s a decent, hardworking man who knows jail operations from the bottom-up, but he’s also defensive and hardheaded. When criticized, he digs in, instead of reaching out and building relationships to correct problems. He’s not smooth enough to handle public relations. He comes off as indifferent, even callous, when confronted by angry and grieving families following a jail fatality.

Advertise with us

Mr. Harper is also, I suspect, tired of the bullseye on his back and ready to get out of Dodge.

Start recruiting now

Truth be told, County Executive Rich Fitzgerald should have fired the warden two or three years ago. The next county executive must pay far more attention to the local jail than did Mr. Fitzgerald, who was MIA until mid-2022, when he, wisely, authorized an independent review of jail fatalities.

Among other things, the leading candidates for county executive should start looking now for a new warden.

Democratic state Rep. Sara Innamorato, who won Tuesday’s primary, and Republican Joe Rockey, who ran unopposed, will face off in November. Both could start their own national search for a warden immediately — if they haven’t already. Or the two county executive candidates and Mr. Fitzgerald could conduct a search together. As the sitting county executive, Mr. Fitzgerald has the legitimacy and resources to undertake a thorough and transparent search for a new warden, including bringing candidates to Pittsburgh. Mr. Fitzgerald is also the one person who could ask Mr. Harper to resign, while a search for a successor continued.

Advertise with us

A joint recruitment effort could also help smooth the hand-off between the Fitzgerald Administration and whatever comes next, avoiding the sloppy and disastrous transition that occurred between the Peduto and Gainey administrations.

The easiest route for Mr. Fitzgerald would be to wash his hands of the jail in his final months, and focus on the issues for which he has expertise and passion. But he owes the people his best parting efforts on the jail, whether that means working with two county executive candidates he opposed in the primaries, or cutting loose the man he appointed to run the jail more than a decade ago.

Pulitzer Prize-winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.