Most Americans believe in equality, or at least they say they do. It’s even canonized in the nation’s founding documents, including the Declaration of Independence, that “all men are created equal . . . endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights.”
Equality in 1776, of course, applied only to wealthy white men. Over decades and centuries, however, the U.S. Constitution and law expanded to cover all people, at least in theory. The ideal of equality transcends abilities, talents and aptitudes. It means we all have an intrinsic and equal value as human beings.
But in practice, equality isn’t real, even under the law. The legal and criminal justice system treat people in widely divergent ways. Prisons and jails are full of people who are poor and disproportionately Black and brown. And people who can afford to pay $300,000 for an attorney will fare better than those who must rely on the public defense system.
The law is not the only arena where equality is more of an idea than a reality. Nowhere is it less real than in my profession: the media.
The national media coverage of the killings of four University of Idaho students has been massive, especially in the two weeks following the Dec. 30 arrest of suspect Bryan Kohberger, 28. The stabbing deaths of Kaylee Goncalves, 21; Madison Mogen, 21; Xana Kernoldle, 20; and Ethan Chapin, 20, mattered a lot, even to people who didn’t know them.
The tsunami of media coverage followed by the whole country might have troubled some of the victims’ families, but it may also have comforted them. Intense grief can become extremely isolating. During a CNN interview, Ms. Mogen’s father said he felt better knowing the entire nation seemed to support the victims’ families.
During my 13 years as a columnist for the Detroit Free Press, from 2000 to 2013, I wrote about many deaths, and lives, that didn’t seem to matter to the media or anyone else. Unlike the father of Madison Mogen, their families felt isolated, without support, even from the police.
I remember Sophia Williams, whose 15-year-old daughter, Bryona, was abducted in Detroit in March of 2003. No one searched for Bryona, except for her mother and dozens of her friends and relatives. Police initially dismissed the case as a runaway. Bryona’s disappearance wasn’t mentioned by any media outlet.
Three weeks after her abduction, Bryona’s frozen body was found, nude form the waist down, in an abandoned house on Detroit’s eastside. She had been raped and strangled. Even then, the media nearly ignored the story. This happened at about the same time a 15-year-old girl from Salt Lake City, Utah, Elizabeth Smart, was found. Her disappearance nine months earlier had triggered a nationwide manhunt and saturated national media coverage.
Two lost girls. Two very different responses.
I remember the Three T’s: Taurean Lewis, Terry Canty Jr. and Anthony Collins. The three best friends and college students were shot to death, execution style, in a friend’s house on Detroit’s eastside. The triple homicide also was nearly ignored by the media.
Police respond to public pressure, or the lack of it. When I left Detroit six years later, the case of the Three T’s was still unsolved.
There are some rational reasons for some of the difference in coverage between Elizabeth Smart and Bryona Williams, and between the murders of three college students in Detroit and four in Idaho.
Murder is much more unusual — and, thus, newsworthy — in Moscow, Idaho, than in Detroit, and the Three T’s were murdered during a bloody six days in which 14 other people were shot to death in Detroit.
But timing and journalistic conventions don’t entirely explain the difference between one back-page story in the local paper and intense, multi-media coverage across the country.
I’m not saying the murders of Bryona Williams and the Three T’s were ignored because they were poor and Black. But I am saying the lack of coverage in those cases — and the superficial and thoughtless way we in the media sometimes handle those stories — makes it easier for other people not to care.
When journalists view death and tragedy through a wildly unequal lens, when some deaths and tragedies matter so much more than others, the message to the families and people in those communities, and to readers and viewers, is that those lives don’t matter much. In Detroit or Pittsburgh, that’s the wrong message to send.
Pulitzer Prize winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.