Even people who support the progressive politics of John Fetterman — and I’m one of them — would admit he’s a crappy dresser, even while campaigning for a U.S Senate seat.

Supporters of his Republican opponent, Mehmet Oz, call Mr. Fetterman’s trademark cargo shorts and hoodie a contrived costume and political ploy, calculated to disguise his privileged background. But Mr. Fetterman’s style, or lack of it, might simply be John Fetterman being John Fetterman. For the lieutenant governor of Pennsylvania, being John Fetterman has worked out pretty well.

Either way, no Black man running for the U.S. Senate could get away with campaigning in cargo shorts and a hoodie. It’s something only an entitled white man would or could do. Mr. Fetterman should remember that as his political ambitions become bigger, broader and more diverse.

It’s no accident that Black men have made up most of the nation’s most stylish and best-dressed politicians and activists. Consider former San Francisco Mayor Willie Brown, clean as the Board of Health in his Borsalino fedora hats and Brioni suits. Or Adam Clayton Powell Jr., New York’s first African American congressman, who occasionally flossed in silk Ascots.

Advertise with us

Black activist Cornel West, a former Harvard University philosophy professor, coordinates his progressive, left-wing politics with tailored three-piece suits and gold cufflinks. Malcolm X, a genuine revolutionary, was a conservative but impeccable dresser, taking his early sartorial cues from the Nation of Islam, whose somber suits and bow ties signified self-respect and scared the hell out of white people. Malcolm had several pairs of his trademark horn-rimmed glasses with different-hued stems to complement his suits. Imagine him delivering a fiery speech in Harlem wearing sweats.

No doubt, health care, inflation, living-wage jobs, climate change, education, an oppressive criminal justice system and other issues overshadow what a candidate wears. Like many people, I applaud what Mr. Fetterman has said on them. Even so, it’s at least remotely possible that his sub-zero style quotient, coupled with his upscale background, could affect a few votes in a tight election.

Motown style

Black voters will be the difference-makers in this race, as they are in many elections. Like anyone else, Black people will vote for the candidate they think will best represent their interests. As a progressive Democrat, Mr. Fetterman will almost certainly get most of the Black vote, regardless of what he wears. To prevail, however, he will have to win big in the Black community, and political strategists already predict a low turnout among African Americans for Pennsylvania’s midterms. If Mr. Fetterman loses, it will be because he did not, or could not, motivate Black voters to turn out for him in overwhelming numbers.

My hometown, Detroit, is a good place to observe what clothes say about class, culture and race. In one of the nation’s poorest and Blackest cities, many people are struggling and hustling to survive. Even so, you’d be hard-pressed to find a city where men dress with more style, creativity and care. Dressing is a fine art in Detroit, a competitive sport, as well as a form of self-expression and self-affirmation. Even on their worst days, men try to stay sharp.

Advertise with us

By contrast, Mr. Fetterman, 53, seems more at home with rural white voters, and dresses like he doesn’t give a damn. His persona, punctuated by a shaved head, is more heavy metal and grunge than hip-hop and jazz. The skin-head look could backfire in spots like North Philadelphia and Pittsburgh’s Homewood neighborhood, or among African American voters in general.

The Oz factor

Mr. Oz, statistically, should not do well with Black voters, but he understands the power of the Black vote and could do better than expected. The celebrity talk show host and former surgeon has campaigned in urban neighborhoods, especially in Philadelphia. In 2020, the Doctor Oz Show launched the #MoreBlackDoctors campaign to push for more diversity in medicine. Mr. Oz, 62, has appeared dozens of times on Oprah Winfrey’s daytime talk show. (Ms. Winfrey has neither endorsed nor opposed Mr. Oz’s senate campaign.)

Pennsylvania’s Democratic Party seems oblivious to all this and hasn’t done enough to motivate Black voters. For starters, Democratic strategists should have made sure the suit Mr. Fetterman wore during Tuesday’s night debate didn’t hang on his six-foot-eight frame like a tent.

Shaking his Borsalino, Willie Brown would not have approved.

Pulitzer-Prize winner Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.