At 3 a.m. on a freezing night in January, I waited at a traffic light at Penn and Ninth, my eyelids fluttering with fatigue. Three loud thumps on the passenger-side window snapped me to attention. A Black man in his early 20s peered through the window, circling his hand.

“What’s up?” I barked, as the window dropped.

Knowing he wanted money, I considered my options. I heard him say “diabetic,” “insulin” and something about needing to eat before dialysis treatment. Then I remembered I left my wallet at my North Shore hotel, where I was staying for six weeks as I started a job as the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette’s editorial page editor.

Undeterred, the panhandler offered to ride back to the hotel with me.

Advertise with us

“Get in,” I said.

His name was Cedrick. Exchanging small talk, we rode the half-mile to the hotel, where he waited in the lobby while I went to my room, grabbed a $20 bill and took it to him. After thanking me twice, Cedrick disappeared into the darkness.

Did I do the right thing, or play the chump again?

It’s a question I’ve pondered daily since returning to a real city in December. After nearly 20 years in Detroit, home to roughly 15,000 homeless people, I spent most of the next five years in rural Western Pennsylvania and East Texas, where, despite hard-knock poverty, panhandling was rare.

Now I live in Pittsburgh’s Cultural District, a mile from the Post-Gazette. During my nightly walk home, an average of four to five panhandlers hit me up for cash, making the walk almost as expensive as cab fare.

Advertise with us

To its credit, Pittsburgh has no laws against panhandling. Many other cities, by enacting anti-panhandling ordinances, have criminalized mental illness, addiction and homelessness, shoving people into a revolving door of jail, fines, unemployment and dependency.

I’m human. Occasionally, after getting accosted five or six times, my baser instincts take over. Flashing a look that means, GET THE HELL OUT OF MY FACE, I move on. More often than not, however, I give panhandlers a dollar.

No doubt, a minority of them use the money for drugs or alcohol, but I can’t assume the person in front of me will despite all I know about the horrors of addiction. Besides, whether I give to people is my business. What people do with the money is theirs.

I know I have been scammed, but that doesn’t mean the next person will fool me. And just because someone runs a scam doesn’t mean he doesn’t need money.

I suspect I’m getting something out of this, too. Maybe giving to panhandlers makes me feel good or superior to people who don’t. Maybe I’m compensating for all the crappy things I’ve done. Guilt comes naturally to me. It’s hard for me to walk by a guy asking for a little jingle when I’m wearing an Armani suit.

Advertise with us

I grew up thirsty. Long-expired food stamps, the tarnished lunch bucket I carried into the factory and the memory of those worn-out work boots I wore in grade school remind me of another life. But I was never desperate enough to panhandle. It’s tough for me to ask anyone for anything. Truth be told, I’d feel more comfortable robbing people than asking them for money.

Every panhandler has a story, and I don’t presume to know it.

One in five persons in Pittsburgh is poor; at any moment, nearly 900 are homeless. Far more are homeless at some time during the year. Still, not all poor or homeless people panhandle. Most do not. Not all panhandlers are homeless. Some have apartments.

Panhandling may be a side hustle, but people don’t get rich off it. Panhandlers tell me they make $20 a day, or less.

Some cities have parking-style meters or sidewalk boxes where people can donate money to food banks or shelters, instead of giving it to panhandlers. That’s fine, but it’s no long-term solution to the problems of mental illness, addiction, a lack of affordable housing or a federal minimum wage that has risen by only $3 an hour in 34 years.

Advertise with us

So when a panhandler approaches you, what should you do?

I asked Jerrel Gilliam, executive director of Light of Life Rescue Mission in Pittsburgh. He knows a lot about people in trouble. His agency provides emergency shelter, recovery support for drug addiction, hundreds of meals a day and other services to the poor.

Mr. Gilliam doesn’t recommend giving money to panhandlers but, instead, offering healthy snacks or juices or even buying them lunch. Above all, he told me, treat people right. Compassion and respect are especially important to people who rarely experience them.

If panhandlers and homeless people make you uncomfortable, get over it. If you don’t want to give — don’t — but look people in the eye, speak to them. Recognize their humanity.

That’s the only real advice I can give. We all need recognition and respect. It’s the least you can give, but it’s golden.

Jeffery Gerritt is the editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette.