Last Sunday in Miami, Paul Skenes walked to the mound at LoanDepot Park to face a Dominican Republic lineup that had scored 51 runs in five World Baseball Classic games, clubbed a tournament-record 15 home runs and mercy-ruled two opponents.

It included Juan Soto, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Fernando Tatis Jr. and Manny Machado — a batting order that multiple commentators called the best ever assembled for international play. Skenes used a 97-mph fastball to hold them to one run on six hits over 4⅓ innings, escaped a bases-loaded jam in the fourth, and left with a 2-1 lead that the bullpen held in a thrilling semifinal.

Here is the part where we Pittsburghers should stop and recognize the greatness of the pitcher we’re privileged to still watch. For now. Enjoy his greatness while it lasts because in Pittsburgh, nothing does.

After all, the city peaked long ago, reaching 677,000 people in 1950 when the steel mills produced nearly half the nation’s output, and the city was the forge of the American century. Today, the population sits just a hair above 300,000. Between 1979 and 1983, the mills shed 150,000 jobs, and the broader metro area has lost 430,000 plus residents since 1970 — a 15% decline during a period when the U.S. population grew 66%, even as the area began to shed jobs and population. Each grew up wearing black and gold, and the franchise grew around them.

Advertise with us

The Homestead Works, which once employed 15,000 steelworkers and produced roughly 8% of the world’s steel, is now a lackluster shopping center. There are no steel mills within city limits. This cycle — build something incredible, watch it leave — repeats across every sector of civic life.

Baseball is no exception, and the timeline is just as predictable. But this time it could be different. In two or three years, we could be dreaming of a World Series.

Pittsburgh’s great pitcher

Through 55 career starts, Skenes owns a 1.96 ERA — the lowest by any pitcher through his first two MLB seasons since 1920. His 2025 campaign produced a unanimous Cy Young: a 1.97 ERA, 216 strikeouts in 187⅔ innings, a franchise-record strikeout rate, and a 217 ERA+. He became only the second pitcher in history to win Rookie of the Year one season and the Cy Young the next, matching the stellar ascent of the Mets’ Dwight Gooden in 1984–85.

The best pitcher in baseball now plays for the Pittsburgh Pirates. Since the bygone days of Honus Wagner, who retired in 1917, how often has that been true of any position?

You can count those instances within a living fan’s memory on one hand. Roberto Clemente was the best right fielder in baseball from roughly 1961 through 1972. He was an MVP in 1966, 12 consecutive Gold Gloves, and the 1971 World Series MVP performance before his death on New Year’s Eve in 1972. Willie Stargell, who won the 1979 NL MVP at 39 alongside the “We Are Family” World Series title, was always good but never quite the best player in the game at his position even during his peak years.

Advertise with us

What both men shared, though, was that they stayed. Clemente was a Pirate for life. Stargell was a Pirate for life. They grew old in black and gold, and the franchise grew around them. That stopped after 1979.

Dave Parker, who won the NL MVP in 1978 and was arguably the game’s most complete outfielder from 1977 through 1979, cratered amid cocaine parties, weight gain and injuries before disembarking for Cincinnati. The game’s all-time brightest star, Barry Bonds, won two MVPs and three Gold Gloves during his Pittsburgh years from 1986 to 1992, then walked to San Francisco as a free agent because the Pirates wouldn’t pay him.

Andrew McCutchen owned a four-year peak from 2012 to 2015 that included an MVP and four Silver Sluggers — then was traded to the Giants for prospects once that competitive, entertaining and ultimately disappointing window slammed shut.

Pittsburgh’s pattern

The pattern after the Clemente-Stargell era is consistent: Pittsburgh produces a generational talent, enjoys a brief spell of success with him and watches him leave.

Skenes is under club control through 2029. An extension would require the largest contract in Pirates history by a wide margin; the franchise’s biggest commitment to date is Bryan Reynolds’ seven-year, $100 million deal. If Skenes hits free agency at 27, his contract will likely exceed $400 million spread over eight to 10 years — the sort of thing only a metro area like New York, Los Angeles or (perish the thought) Philadelphia could afford.

Advertise with us

GM Ben Cherington told reporters in November that “Paul Skenes is going to be a Pirate in 2026.” What about afterward?

There is a case that the foundation around Skenes is now sturdier than it was around McCutchen. Bubba Chandler, the top pitching prospect in baseball per ESPN, averaged 99.1 mph this spring and struck out eight Braves in five innings last week. If he develops as projected, the Pirates will have two front-of-the-rotation arms under cost control simultaneously, a luxury this franchise has almost never had. Mitch Keller is a solid mid-rotation innings-eater. Reynolds, signed through 2030, provides a dependable piece.

And then there is Oneil Cruz, the 6-foot-7 center fielder with 100th-percentile bat speed, 20 home runs and 38 stolen bases last year despite a .200 average — the most tantalizing gap between tools and production in baseball. If Cruz’s off-season swing work translates to even league-average contact, and heavyset free agent slugger Marcell Ozuna still has that 30-homer pop in his bat, the Pirates have a dangerous lineup to pair with the pitching.

Pittsburgh’s ticking clock

That is a lot of ifs for a franchise that has made the playoffs three times since 1992. Skenes, after winning the Cy Young, told local media his goal is to “win a World Series in Pittsburgh” and that 2025 was a “wasted year” if the Pirates didn’t learn from it. He talked about channeling the city’s blue-collar identity. In a perfect world, he ends up the next Clemente or Stargell — a lifer, not a rental.

Whether he gets the chance depends on an ownership group that has steadfastly refused to invest in success. The clock is always ticking in Pittsburgh. And time begins on Opening Day.

Oliver Bateman, a contributing writer for the Post-Gazette editorial page who writes every other Thursday, is a historian, journalist and author of the Substack “Oliver Bateman Does the Work.” He lives in Pittsburgh. His previous article was “Pennsylvanians grow more critical of ICE.”