A few months ago, a Times/Siena survey reported that a large majority of Americans now believe that we are incapable of overcoming our deep divisions. Other than the economy, polarization was cited as our country’s most urgent problem.
Americans increasingly live in demographically and ideologically distinct communities. We are more likely to make decisions that conform to our beliefs than incorporate other points of view.
This affects the arts as much as anyone. Nonprofit arts programmers have responded to this narrowing of vision by increasing the diversity of leadership and by presenting a greater diversity of underrepresented artists. But our nonprofit venues, where the artists are heard, remain gated communities.
Collective effervescence
Accidentally, City of Asylum discovered an audience-oriented strategy in 2005 when we presented a public program to introduce our first exiled writer-in-residence. (I was a co-founder and still serve on the board.)
We had no facility, so we set up a stage and 300 folding chairs on a closed street, with free admission and no reserved seats. Over 500 people came, and we saw how neighbors in our own polarized community and city-wide strangers from all walks of life interacted.
The effect of the poet Huang Xiang’s performance — entirely in Chinese, in collaboration with the jazz saxophonist Oliver Lake — on this randomly commingled audience of non-Chinese speakers was unexpected. His performance was electric, but the context changed the audience experience.
One person wrote, “I did not understand what he was saying, but the way it was presented made your mind go ‘whoop’”; another that “this was one of the most amazing experiences I have experienced in any city.”
We didn’t know it at the time, but we had created what the 19th century sociologist Emil Durkheim called “collective effervescence,” except with a key difference. Durkheim’s collective is enclosed by a “boundary between participants and outsiders.” Our audience on the street had a borderless, open experience of community. As Lake wrote in a poem, “No separation, all on the same plate.”
This inspired us to present literary and jazz programs in homes, gardens and vacant lots throughout our community. In 2017 we opened our own venue, Alphabet City, in a long-abandoned building next to the Garden Theater on the North Side, a few blocks west of Allegheny General Hospital.
Differences without polarization
Our goal was to create a place of regional impact, where the audience experience would replicate that of our first public program, with few barriers of access so people from all walks of life would come together around the art. Artists are paid, but tickets to every program — 120 to 160 a year — are all free. There are no reserved seats or dress codes, and there are many accommodations for those living with disabilities.
Within the space, there are plenty of differences, in background and opinion, but without polarization. Our revenue comes from mission-based donations in campaigns not ticket sales, support that is purposeful rather than transactional.
Our approach is far from perfect, but we are making progress. City of Asylum’s audiences are 50% more representative of our local population than the national benchmark. And in surveys about our programs, over 80% of respondents regularly confirm that they understand someone better as a result of attending a program, and over 70% engage in a conversation with someone new at a program.
By contrast, audiences nationally are monocultures in venues where seating is polarized by price. They have become less open to new experiences, gravitating to familiar artists and familiar programs. And the cost of tickets has limited access. For example, the NEA reported that 38% of U.S. adults and almost half of those ages 18 to 24, Hispanic or African American find access to arts and cultural activities challenging.
Exclusion and polarization inhibit social “affective” cohesion — the bonds among us that are the foundation of democratic civic life and of a just community. Heterogenous audience experiences create empathy and humanize polarity. When these irruptions of hospitality persist, their impact is cumulative.
“In the same way we need to go to the gym to exercise our physical bodies,” political scientist Hahrie Han explains, “we need gyms for democracy — places where we can develop the habits and skills to … engage people who are different from us, to learn habits of tolerance.”
Reducing the polarity
The art presented by nonprofits can challenge or be esoteric, and free ticketing is neither a panacea nor a doable solution for all organizations. But by expanding access, we can do our part in reducing the polarity that threatens American democracy.
For example, there are many unused seats at arts programs — estimates range from 15% to almost 40%. These empty seats are an immense and squandered asset. How can we fill them with people who want them but can’t afford them or are otherwise excluded and make them feel welcome when they come?
Together as a sector, we must use our creativity to help break down the walls that divide our communities. It is not only a matter of the arts mission in a free society, as I have argued above. But also it is a necessity for our sustainability.
The economist William Baumol wrote extensively about how costs in the arts inexorably outpace inflation for no fault of their own. Maximizing the value of what the arts provide to individuals and society must be made part of our missions, to augment our ticket sales and deserve the support we need.
To create and produce art, we will increasingly depend on what we accomplish in the community.
R. H. Reese is a co-founder, with artist Diane Samuels, of City of Asylum Pittsburgh. They led the organization as volunteers from 2004 to 2020 and continue on the board. Reese was formerly a principal in Reese Brothers Teleservices.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.