Building on the “Big Idea” series of editorials, we are publishing a series of “Your Big Idea” from Pittsburghers with their own ambitious plans for the city and region.
If you want people to come Downtown, especially during the day, you have to give them a reason. We have been so focused as a city on the arts and sports that the third, and to some most appealing form of entertainment, has been dismissed as somehow a thing of the past.
I’m talking about shopping, about building a retail corridor that will draw from across the region because it offers an assortment of stores not found in malls and more important, that can only be found Downtown.
We don’t have that now. But we could if we applied the same seduction malls use to attract anchors, and Pittsburgh has used to woo airlines. Namely subsidies.
The Allegheny County Airport Authority paid British Airways close to $4 million to provide international flights from Pittsburgh beginning in 2019. In 2023 it offered Icelandair $350,000 and a two-year gate fee waiver to serve Pittsburgh. And in December it was announced the state will provide $5.25 million over two years to bring Aer Lingus here.
What if we — as a city, a state or an economic development engine — subsidized a Downtown anchor store that would draw competitors, who would together draw shoppers Downtown? Offer them a space rent-free for three years and build it out to their specifications. In return they stock it and staff it.
Start with Zara
My choice would be Zara, the hugely popular chain known for its trendy, inexpensive clothing for men and women. It’s about the only store that has the clout to do what our city needs. The Spanish company is building 98 new stores worldwide this year and is expanding its footprint in the United States. Pittsburgh is not in its plans — yet.
Why Zara? Because where Zara goes, Mango, a competing Spanish chain, follows. And so does Uniqlo, the Japanese store known for cheap but great fashion. Throw in Muji, another Japanese chain that offers chic housewares in addition to clothing. All of these stores attract an age range of customers from young and hip to working women to the suburban moms who’ve outgrown Talbots.
Identifying which stores to attract is the first step. The Guccis and Louis Vuittons can stay at the mall. They probably feel safer there anyway, and they don’t have a mass clientele. But the second step is creating an environment in which the stores can thrive and are supported by ancillary businesses, such as glass-fronted cafes for people watching, restaurants and a Rita’s.
Imagine a pedestrian throughfare that is closed to traffic, lined with trees and benches and outdoor dining in the summer. Imagine several blocks of small and larger shops, a mix of local businesses and chains. It works in London and Paris and Rome and Amsterdam. Why not Pittsburgh?
The two blocks of Fifth Avenue between Smithfield and Liberty would be ideal. It is bordered on Smithfield by the Target in the former Kaufmann’s — one of the more successful urban Targets, which tells us something. At the other end is the Fairmont Hotel.
In between there are already several nice anchors — the Capitol Grille, McCormick & Schmick’s, clothing retailers Larrimor’s and Heinz Healy, Izzazu Salon, Vallozzi’s restaurant and of course, PNC’s headquarters. A collection of smaller storefronts are ripe for re-invention as small businesses.
Remove the albatross
And then there is the albatross — Warner Centre, currently for sale. No one has figured out what to do with that odd space, which has gone through several incarnations, all of them gloomy. The building has a rather attractive classic façade if you take down the Warner sign that shrieks “I’m clinging to the past” 40 years after the theater closed.
The inside has been jury-rigged so many times the best thing is probably to gut it and reconfigure that cavernous space. Turn it into, let’s say, Zara!
Those two blocks lead directly to the Cultural District at one end and connect to both Market Square and Point Park University on the side. And within a few blocks any which way, thanks to our compact Golden Triangle, there are more hotels and restaurants.
Not to mention ample parking with garages on Oliver, Forbes and Liberty. Retractable barricades could be installed at the Wood Street intersection, and the valet parking there at night could be extended into the day.
Think of a pedestrian Fifth as the connecting vein that runs through the vertical heart of the city, an artery filled with life that could be open seven days a week and evenings.
Of course, the buses would have to go and the police would have to come. Feeling safe is essential, especially if the stores are to stay open late (as they do everywhere else) and the restaurants are to attract evening diners including the après theater/concert/game goers who now go home hungry.
With so much residential conversion planned and Downtown living up 43% in five years, having a shopping district is more than a next step — It’s a major attraction to help fill the more than 1,000 units in the works. And don’t get me started on the poor office workers who might as well eat lunch at their desks!
Retail will work Downtown
The lament for so long has been that retail doesn’t work Downtown. Sure, our department stores closed. They’ve closed throughout the country as shopping habits have changed. Besides, Pittsburgh was always pegged as a C market.
It doesn’t mean the desire to shop had been eradicated, to see and touch and try on, to get excited by something in a window. Pittsburghers are way more stylish than retailers think.
But beyond the shopping, having a pedestrian street in the middle of Downtown provides a place of community, and that leads to a sense of community. Ask most people what they do when they go to other cities, and I’d wager shopping would be near the top of many lists.
So let’s give some incentive to Fifth Avenue property owners to convert some of their real estate, break some bigger spaces into smaller ones, rent with an eye toward creating a welcoming shopping district. Let’s bribe Zara to come. If we build it, so will everyone else.
Marylynn Uricchio was the film critic, Seen and style editor of the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette for many years. She now writes about design for Pittsburgh Quarterly Magazine.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.