As a rule, I would have passed right by a store called, Sacred Heart of Jesus, but given that Dan and I were in Pittsburgh on vacation, we went in. Sisters Sharon and Maria Madeleine couldn’t have been more welcoming.
They guided us through the requisite holy cards and patron saint medals, plus a vintage section with mid-century icons and figures. Upon discovering that we were visiting from California and newcomers to Pittsburgh, they were pleasantly surprised that we were spending time in their humble city.
We assured them we loved it, citing museums, the Allegheny Cemetery and vibrant neighborhoods. (Plus I have a soft spot for cities that are regaining some of their former grandeur, like my hometown of Baltimore.)
The sisters became the first in a series of locals we conversed with at length, and recommended restaurants and sections of town not to be missed. “Get the bacon cheeseburger with the double blue cheese at Tessaro’s!” said Sister Sharon excitedly, referring to a joint just up street. We did exactly that, later in the day, with no regrets.
Off-the-radar
As we were heading out, the sisters, in unison, pointed to a book: “If you sign this, we’ll pray for you.” It didn’t seem appropriate to ask “Why?” or “For how long?” Never-theless, we signed. And hearing that we intended to snap a selfie out front with their store sign behind us, Sister Sharon stepped out and took our photo.
“Do you think they knew we were a couple?” Dan asked, when they were out of hearing distance.
“Hard to say. But they seemed genuinely friendly.”
I’m fortunate that my husband is open to off-the-radar travel destinations like Pittsburgh. Ten years ago, we landed on a clear afternoon and drove into the city at dusk, full moon rising in the east. We located our vacation digs, hastily unpacked, and made a beeline for Station, a nearby restaurant.
Choosing Arbnb’s in an unfamiliar city can be a crapshoot, but strolling past Liberty Street shops like Big Idea Bookstore and Donatelli’s market (which sadly closed in 2022), we discovered we’d landed in a hip, walkable neighborhood — the Bloomfield, or Little Italy, neighborhood.
Locals chatted with us in a down-to-earth manner so regularly during our week that the friendliness of Pittsburgh stands out as much as the eateries, culture, and rivers and bridges. When we met Gina, the owner of Linea Verde, a small produce store, her first comment to us was pure sarcasm, so naturally we became fast friends. We’d update her on our adventures at the Warhol Museum or the Bloomfield Bridge Tavern (wonderful Polish food, but now closed) during our frequent chats.
People happy to be back
Atop the Monongahela Incline, we talked to a guy and his teenage daughter for a long stretch, pointing out the sky-high housing costs of the Bay Area compared to Pittsburgh’s, while he pointed out his childhood street in Oakland in the panorama below. He’d lived else-where for awhile but was happy to be back in Pittsburgh and proud of its ongoing recovery.
At an open home in Schenley Farms, a neighborhood we’d just spied from the 36th floor of the Cathedral of Learning, we compared notes with the seller, Julia. Her plan was to “return to Southern California and leave Pittsburgh and its dreary winters behind,” while we marveled at the thought of living in a less frenetic context. Being a landscaper by trade, I appreciated her street’s canopy of mature trees native to Western Pennsylvania.
It’s hard to measure such interactions, but they stood out.
Toward the end of the 1900s, Pittsburgh’s failing industries and hard times were well-publicized, but by 2016 the economy was rallying back — on the larger scale, partly through technology and healthcare, and on the smaller scale, by reinventing: the Church Brew Works, for instance.
A Roman Catholic church was transformed into an award-winning brewery, with beers like “Pious Monk” and “Celestial Gold.” The place was packed. We were instant converts. We noted that Sister Sharon had somehow omitted that recommendation.
We realize, that as tourists, we get to enjoy the benefits of gentrification in neighborhoods like Shadyside and Lawrenceville without any of the downsides. Vacationing in a city is one thing, but day-to-day life there is quite another.
Driving through the once-thriving Hill District and other less fortunate sections was a revelation, illustrating to us a fraction of the fascinating cultural and economic ups and downs of a complicated city.
Black and gold
Still, Pittsburgh was a blast. We recommend it to folks and would visit again. Two months after our return, I unwrapped a Christmas present from Dan — an oversized, two-dollar plastic rosary, handmade by the nuns at the Sacred Heart of Jesus store in the black and gold team colors of the Pittsburgh Steelers.
It’s been on our Christmas tree every year since, reminding us of our wonderful trip, and that in all likelihood, the nuns are still praying for us.
Jim Forgione is a lanscaper and writer living in California and author of a novel, “Surface Tension.” This is an entry in the “First Person” series.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.