The day has already come when American soldiers are patrolling American streets — not to fight an enemy abroad, but to intimidate citizens at home. The day may soon be here when they are sent here to Pittsburgh.
Many commentators have already dissected how such a move undermines our democracy, politicizes the military, and sets us on a path toward authoritarian rule. They’re right, and those critiques matter.
But as residents of Pittsburgh, we face a more immediate question: what do we do when the National Guard actually shows up on our blocks? When you pass them on the sidewalk, when you see them at intersections, when your children ask why soldiers are standing in front of their school, how should you act?
Citizens like us
The temptation to respond with hostility is understandable, but we must resist that impulse. Because the Guardsmen are not the villains of this story. They are citizens, just like us, who have been dragged away from their families, jobs, and communities, and ordered into roles they never signed up for and don’t want.
Our job, as citizens of a democracy under threat, is not to treat them as enemies but to remind them, firmly, constantly, and humanely, that our dispute is not with them, but with the autocratic leadership that abuses their service.
Be polite and friendly. Treat the Guard with basic courtesy. Smile. Wave hello. These are men and women who have been put in an impossible situation. They signed up to protect American values, but their very presence through this deployment violates those values.
They trained to defend the nation, not to police city blocks. Many are as uncomfortable with this deployment as you are.
It may feel counterintuitive, but thank them sincerely for their service. Acknowledge that you value the sacrifices they make to protect America. A kind word costs you nothing, but reminds them of the humanity of the people they are being ordered to watch.
If you have children, introduce them. If you have a puppy, let the Guard pet it. Bring bottles of water on hot days. These small acts of neighborliness matter. They create a sense of connection.
They make it psychologically harder for a Guardsman to see you as an abstraction, as a faceless “crowd.” If they are ever ordered to take violent action, it won’t just be against “civilians” — it will be against the family who offered them a drink, the child who waved hello, the dog that wagged its tail.
Not weakness
This is not weakness. It is strategy. Authoritarians rely on dehumanization to consolidate power. They want soldiers to see citizens as threats, not neighbors. Every act of kindness undercuts that project. Every relationship makes it harder to misuse the Guard as a blunt instrument of repression.
This deployment is wrong. It is a violation of the principles on which this nation was founded. We should be unequivocal in opposing it. But in our daily interactions, we must distinguish between the policy and the people caught in its gears.
We cannot control the orders that come down the chain of command. But we can control how we, as citizens, respond. By treating Guardsmen with respect, by reminding them of their duty, by weaving them into our community rather than pushing them away, we increase the psychological and moral costs of compliance with unlawful orders.
Moments of crisis are rarely the time for careful moral reasoning. Psychological research has shown that when under stress, cognitive load, and time pressure, people rarely have the bandwidth to think through the best course of action. They default to habit and authority.
A test of civic wisdom
By foregrounding the humanity of the communities that they are patrolling, we help members of the National Guard prepare for the pressure should they ever be given an unlawful order. Acts of kindness now pave the path toward more ethical behavior in the future, and can make the difference between blind compliance and principled refusal.
This is not about capitulation. It is about creating conditions where autocratic overreach is harder to execute, where conscience is harder to ignore, and where the Constitution stands a chance of being upheld in the very moments it is most threatened.
The presence of the National Guard on America’s streets is an affront to democracy. But how we treat the Guardsmen themselves is a test of our civic wisdom. Let’s not fail it.
Daniel Oppenheimer is a professor of social and decision sciences at Carnegie-Mellon University and co-author of “Democracy Despite Itself: Why a System that Shouldn’t Work at All Works So Well.” His previous article was “Please do better than you did last time, Mr. President.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.