Visiting New York Yankee fans laughed as Pirates fans chanted “sell the team” during Pittsburgh’s home opener. Why not? The Yankees are stocked with lavishly paid all-stars lured away from Pittsburgh and other smaller market teams that can’t afford enormous payrolls. For Yankee fans, it’s amusing to see little brothers throw tantrums.
Unhappy Pirates fans want owner Bob Nutting to pay more in salaries or sell. They are rightly fed up with losing — as are fans in other major league cities weary of seeing star players hired away.
Pay more for players, they say, or sell the team.
Yet and alas, it’s the wrong chant at the wrong beelzebub.
Rotting baseball
The real issue is that competitive baseball has rotted away in the last half century. The gap between the wealthiest teams and the rest of baseball has grown year by year, and the people who control baseball have allowed it to wreck the sport.
The 10 wealthiest franchises have claimed 26 of the last 50 World Series titles. The other 20 teams won 24. The math: in baseball, if you are rich, you are more than twice as likely to win a World Series.
Fans middle-aged or younger have grown up not knowing that the game wasn’t always like this.
My beloved Pirates wouldn’t have World Series pennants from ’60, ’71 and ’79 if baseball was then what it is now. Clemente, Stargell, Maz and others understandably would have vamoosed to rich teams offering enormous salaries. The only statue outside PNC Park would be Honus Wagner’s.
The Pirates have gone 45 seasons without a World Series game, the longest stretch in 143 years of baseball in Pittsburgh. Call it the Great Desolation.
Pirates ownership changed three times during the Great Desolation and the team nearly decamped for another city. The Pirates had 10 managers and waved goodbye to player after player gobbled up by wealthier teams.
The Yankees plucked more than a few — and have been to nine World Series since the Pirates’ last one.
The villains in this chicanery are easy to spot. The league itself and the players union have fought reforms intended to return baseball to the competitive game it was for most of the 20th century. They have delayed any reckoning for decades.
But one is coming next year. If baseball fans rise up, they might help resurrect the game. Its rules are made of clay, after all, not Allegheny shale.
Falling in love with the Pirates
Before I get preachier, a word about my Pirate bona fides, such as they are. I live in Los Angeles but fell for the Pirates six decades ago after a small brown box arrived for a boy in the Alaska bush. The postmark was May 5, 1967 and the return address: 235 McKee Place, Pittsburgh (since demolished).
Inside was a baseball signed by 19 current or former Pittsburgh Pirates.
The gift came from a stranger. A note introduced him as Col. Elmer Goyer, a U.S. Army veteran the boy discovered later had been felled by shrapnel and gas in WWI. Goyer met the boy’s grandfather at spring training and learned about a grandson who had never been to a baseball game. The boy had no team to root for.
Here, Goyer wrote, pull for these guys.
Do what? The boy didn’t know the Pirates from Cheerios. What’s a Pittsburgh?
Weeks later, however, the 14.7 mile drive to the mailbox yielded a magazine from Goyer. The front and back covers, if opened and laid flat, showed Forbes Field from above at night.
It’s hard to know the exact moment in a life when one’s destiny changes, but this was that.
The boy had never seen a tall building or color TV or a road wider than two lanes. Now he gazed upon a diamond glowing at the center of a ballpark with pillars and brick and ivy — all surrounded by a dark, vast night.
It seemed the only living place on Earth. Here in this glorious image was a team whose players had signed a baseball — for him! The bond was instant and visceral.
Lucky for the boy, he fell for the Pirates before the Great Desolation.
Unfair baseball
At Dodger stadium earlier this season, L.A. slugger Shohei Ohtani strode to the plate with a swagger the Pirates couldn’t muster if they walked as one, which was fitting given that Ohtani’s $70M salary is nearly as much as the entire Pittsburgh roster.
Paul Skenes pitched masterfully that night. As he left the game in the 7th inning, a Los Angeles fan sitting nearby smirked that the young Pirates ace was auditioning to become a Dodger.
It was a “let them eat cake” moment, an epiphany: The ruination of baseball has reached mocking expectation and everyone from New York to L.A. is in on the joke.
Worse, the rest of us accept it, as if a league bent for the monarchs is just the way of things.
As the Post-Gazette’s editorial page editor, Brandon McGinley, wrote in an eloquent, plaintive column, he wishes his son wouldn’t fall in love with the Pirates. Down that path lies only heartbreak.
Unless, finally, baseball smartens up. The most popular sport in America today is professional football and a big reason is that the NFL, like the NHL and NBA, worships at the altar of parity. Every year, almost any team can make it to a championship games.
Those three leagues do not abide the unfairness of baseball. Their rules ensure that each team has roughly the same payroll.
And baseball?
LA pays more than $500 million for players, 5½ times more than Pittsburgh’s $89 million payroll. Pittsburgh’s pay gap with the Yankees and the Mets is nearly as large.
The Dodgers spend more than seven times the payroll of the Miami Marlins. L.A. signed Ohtani from the California Angels, who couldn’t match the $700 million, 10-year Dodger offer.
The Pirates’ highest paid player is Mitch Keller, paid a little over $15 million a year. The Dodgers have eight players who make more than that. Keller is followed by Bryan Reynolds, who makes a little over $12 million. The Dodgers have 12 players who make more than him. You get the idea.
Could Nutting spend more on the Pirates? Maybe? Likely? But add $50 million, add $100 million. The payroll still is dwarfed by the monarchs. The Great Desolation continues.
The gap in baseball
The gap between the monarchs and everyone else stems in part from major demographic changes. Over the last half century, a handful of major metro areas saw their economies boom. Wages, real estate and living costs soared, as did the revenue for their MLB teams.
Let’s pick a date. July 18 was the first game my daughter and I saw in our second visit to Pittsburgh this season. We could get into PNC park for $23 cheap seats or sit behind the Pirates dugout for $126.
Same night, the cheapest Dodger seats are $66 and you need $1043 to sit behind the team’s dugout.
There is more. Dodgers average attendance is 10,000 more than PNC’s capacity and the organization receives $334 million annually from broadcast rights.
Pittsburgh earns $60 million.
Large differences in revenues are not unusual in professional sports. But baseball alone has let its monarchs turn their wealth into injustice — for now. A growing number of baseball owners know fans are angry. They know that if the game isn’t fixed soon, many smaller market franchises like Pittsburgh will be at risk.
Those owners want to impose salary caps after the current contract with the players union expires Dec. 1, 2026. The players union will oppose it. The monarchs will scoff. Their answer to parity has been to share revenues by taxing the monarchs. It’s a smoldering failure but they will undoubtedly float another plan they promise will fix things.
Don’t trust it. Do not believe it.
The solution is obvious from NFL, NHL and NBA history, including Pittsburgh’s. Since the Pirates’ last World Series game, the Steelers have played in five Super Bowls and the Penguins in six Stanley Cup finals.
Without salary caps, Mario and Sid and Big Ben and T.J. and many other brilliant players almost certainly would have gone elsewhere for huge paydays. Wouldn’t you?
This is where fans of the Pirates and the Mariners, Angels, Rockies, A’s, Reds, Royals, Marlins and other vassals of baseball can help. Get out the pitchforks and line up behind the owners demanding caps. Channel the anger. Juice a revolution.
Pirates fans could reach out to counterparts in other cities to create a muscular nationwide organization, sponsored by patrons in major league cities equally weary of baseball’s grotesquery. Share ideas.
A way to save baseball
Here’s one: Organize a nationwide rolling boycott, refusing to go to ballparks one agreed upon day a week, or month, until the game adopts salary caps. Call local sportswriters and pester ESPN relentlessly for coverage. A fan revolt makes great stories.
A boycott unfortunately would hurt the vassals more than the monarchs, whose fans would smugly recommend more cake. But it would send a message:
Enough is enough. The game is broken.
Fix it or we quit it.
Baseball lovers, stop chanting: “Sell the team.”
Make it: “Fix the game.”
Drexel Heickes is a former editor at the Los Angeles Times who comes to Pittsburgh once or twice a summer to watch the Pirates play at PNC Park.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.