Only two presidential candidates have ever campaigned in Butler County. John F. Kennedy came in 1960 and Donald J. Trump in 2020 and 2024.
When he announced in October 2020 that he would be holding a rally in Butler, Democrats, Republicans, political strategists and reporters asked, Why in God’s name is he going to Butler?
It’s reliably Republican. It isn’t going to swing the election and would not swing an election cycle. The few extra votes he might get in the county won’t help much to win the state and its electoral votes. Why go there? There’s a reason no candidate goes there — or to places like it.
I thought the decision was brilliant. Trump understood the importance of a sense of place, and of being rooted in a place, and of the kind of place Butler is. People who make their living in Washington, D.C., rarely do.
They do not understand why people in places like Butler County don’t see never leaving one’s hometown as a bad thing and why instead they honor it as an achievement. They do not understand the value of living close enough to your family to have supper together on Sundays. And they don’t know how to cover these voters because they don’t know anyone like them in their own social circles.
What they missed was what Butler means to the people who live there. And what it would mean to voters who saw the candidate taking the time to campaign in a politically unimportant place, a place like those many of them lived — a mixture of rolling farmland, small towns and small cities, demographically stable with many multi-generational families, independent, culturally traditional, but also people economically vulnerable and politically marginal.
If they understood places like Butler County, their candidates would win more often. And they’d understand why in 2024 Donald Trump won Butler County with 65.7% of the vote, and not only that county, but all the places like it. And that meant the presidency.
The county
The county of Butler, a bucolic region along the sloping western foothills of the Appalachian Mountains, grew out of the county of Allegheny seven years after the end of the Revolutionary War. While the county remained a farming region, the city of Butler became the home of industry giants at the end of the nineteenth century, like the Pullman Standard railcar facility that employed, directly or indirectly, most of the city’s adults.
The men who worked at the facility known colloquially as the “wheel works” made steel railcar wheels for over 150 years. The company funneled millions of dollars into the area’s economy, money that paved roads, improved schools and helped to support local charities.
When war threatened the country, the employees manufactured more than seven million artillery shells and bombs, in addition to rail cars, for American and Allied forces in World War II. After the war, the company, employed 4,000 people.
Its closure in 1980 — as Americans swapped trains for cars — nearly destroyed the community’s hope, prosperity and purpose. The city’s unemployment rate skyrocketed to 17.5% practically overnight. Two years later, Mayor Fred Vero estimated the closure had cost the county $60 million.
Today at the same location sits Butler Works, part of Cleveland Cliffs Inc., producing transformers for electrical grids. It’s the largest industrial employer left in the city.
Even so, the Biden-Harris administration came within a hair of killing the local plant in reaction to pressure from the Sierra Club and other heavily bankrolled and powerful “climate justice,” which sued the Department of Energy for not properly doing its customary six-year review of energy efficiency standards.
People remember that.
Coastal vs. fly-over
Reporters often write about the contrast between coastal elites and the “fly-over country,” but the difference is less rural versus urban or low-density versus high-density, as “placed” versus “placeless,” as Tom Maraffa, professor emeritus of geography at Youngstown State University, once told me.
In short, people who are rooted in their places versus people who are essentially nomads, like reporters and politicos who flock to Washington and New York. Placeless people who share no affinity for rootedness to their hometowns develop an affinity for ideology and abstractions, as opposed to a commitment to neighborhoods and cities. Those I call our cultural curators are too mobile to be rooted.
People who live in Butler are generally not so mobile. It’s not because they are stuck. They want to live in their hometown, near family and friends, and with all their home’s traditions. Many have been tied to their places for generations.
This is why they — even the college-educated — view issues such as climate change and globalization differently. They know what losing a crucial industry to someone’s fear of climate change or to a country with cheap labor and high tariffs will do to the place they love.
The placeless think of global policies, abstract efficiencies, and lofty ideas like social justice. The placed think of how things will affect their neighborhood, town or city.
Because those who value place are skeptical toward certain policies, they’re often accused of ignorance, racism and denialism — all lazy tropes that reporters or Democrats use because they would never dream of thinking about how the policies they champion affect the places rooted people love.
Off to East Palestine
But Butler wasn’t the first crucial visit Trump made in his campaign for president. On February 3, 2023, a Norfolk Southern train derailed in East Palestine, Ohio, spilling vinyl chloride and butyl acrylate. The chain of events began with a fiery derailment, followed by a controlled burn that released hydrogen chloride and phosgene into the air and water.
Less than three weeks later, Trump showed up at East Palestine — when President Joe Biden didn’t. Young and old, male and female, Democrats and Republicans, and even the traditionally crowd-shy Amish families all stood in the icy rain as Trump drove into town. With him was the young U.S. senator JD Vance who had been sworn into office less than a month earlier.
I call it his inflection point. I wrote in my rain-smudged reporter’s notebook: “If he is able to resurrect the magic of 2016, understanding the forgotten man and woman and the dignity of work, it started here, the day he showed up when Biden refused.” Trump understood that everyone’s lives there had changed on February 3.
He also understood the significance of almost three weeks of silence from the White House. Newsweek searched the 380 messages released to the White House press pool from the day of the crash to the day Trump arrived in East Palestine and found no direct statements from Biden on the community.
Someone had to tell these people that he saw them and understood their fear and anger and pain. “You are not forgotten,” he said at a news conference, flanked by cases of “Trump” bottled water that he had brought for residents of the community.
He looked at the audience and said, “In too many cases, your goodness and perseverance were met with indifference and betrayal.” He then walked through the village, wearing a long overcoat, his trousers tucked into Carhartt boots, and talked with people about how the train derailment had changed their lives and likely those of generations to come.
One resident, Tami Tsai, told me, “In a lot of ways, we are the symbol or poster child of the kind of place Washington forgets. President Biden underscored that by not coming then or now or ever.” (He did not go to East Palestine until February 16, 2024.)
Unless someone “experienced what we did,” she said, “unless you understood what it is like to be discarded as not important enough, Trump showing up for us showed he cared. There will always be people who said it was a stunt. Well, he didn’t have to do it, but he did. That is more than I can say for President Biden.”
Trump’s visit reminded people that he was physically there for them at a time when they were hurt and worried. He told them, “I am ready to fight for you.” It’s a phrase he would use seventeen months later when he returned to Butler.
Tied to home
Former Allegheny County executive Rich Fitzgerald used to say that eight out of ten people in the region live within eight miles of where they grew up. It is a rootedness that has held for generations. A recent study from researchers at the Census Bureau and Harvard University found that 60% of young adults (the study measured people at age twenty-six) live within 10 miles of where they grew up and 80% live within 100 miles.
Maraffa told me, “People who voted for Trump share a rootedness in place. Think of people in JD Vance’s ‘Hillbilly Elegy’ or the TV series ‘Justified,’ which was tied by the phrase ‘We dug coal together,’ an expression of place.”
Butler matters because it represents so much more than Butler. Tens of millions of people across the country are much the same as the people of the county, people who work with their hands, work the land, and even work in C-suites. Perhaps they could make more money elsewhere, but they decided to stay near their hometown because they were tied to the region and that had more value to them than money.
Donald Trump rolled into Butler on July 13, one year ago today. He didn’t need to win more votes in Butler County. By being seen in Butler County, caring about its people’s concerns, he’d win a lot more votes in the country from people who recognized in Butler County their own homes. Butler represents places with a sense of place, a sense Washington doesn’t understand.
North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner and a contributor to the Washington Post. This is adapted from her new book “Butler: The Untold Story of the Near Assassination of Donald Trump and the Fight for America’s Heartland.” zito.salena@gmail.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.