“You know, Vanni,” one the most distinguished classicists of his time told me decades ago, “with the ever-decreasing number of people voting in elections, and similarly declining standards in clarity of thought and commitment to ideals, it is just possible that one day an unstable extremist may be legitimately elected President of the United States.”

I told Seth Benardete that our constitutional tradition would protect us. Yes, he said, but “we don’t want to find ourselves in that situation in the first place.”

As I have been reflecting on how we have found ourselves in that situation, I wondered what I could add to the flaws my great professor listed, taking into account what developments have occurred since that late Cold War conversation. And I came to the conclusion that the waning civic virtue and cultural quality which so worried Prof. Benardete had combined with our victory in that global struggle to lead America into the deadliest sin in Greek tragedy: hybris.

Land of complacency

Hybris, or hubris, is an excessive pride born of the belief that one’s way of being is absolutely right, and the consequent sense of invincibility. This inevitably “tempts the gods,” who strike down the offender in terrible ways.

Advertise with us

Since the gods of Greek myth are symbols of elemental forces ranging from the sea to wisdom, what these dramas show is that the arrogant hero has become fundamentally out of touch with reality.

Post-Cold War America incontestably suffered from this disconnect. We did not defeat the Soviet Union in a shooting war, but prevailed largely because the world preferred our model of society to theirs. This triumph blinded us to the serious domestic flaws we did have, a vainglory which reached its height in Vice President Dick Cheney’s post-9/​11 declaration that “The American way of life is non-negotiable.”

This attitude flies in the face of the basic fact that all nations, however great, must adapt to changing circumstances, and must never forget what made them great.

During the dozen years from the Fall of the Berlin Wall to 9/​11, Americans were materially comfortable, highly complacent and had little experience of real danger. They were mesmerized, as they still are, by a shallow and often disgusting mass culture which has largely replaced the religious scriptures and classical literature that formerly interpreted the human condition, making life bearable and giving it meaning.

Without these essential texts to guide them, and believing that there were no serious threats on the horizon, Americans forgot the suffering and sacrifices that had made the country so great and prosperous.

Advertise with us

America the unready

By the time that complacency was shattered on 9/​11, many Americans had lost the habit of submitting to duty and hardship that had brought the nation safely through previous historical storms, always emerging with increased power and an enhanced standing in the world. The deceptive ease of the initial victories in Afghanistan and Iraq, together with the lack of a draft, meant that most people were unaffected by the wars, and assumed that the danger had passed.

Yet the full story of how Islamic extremism had become a global threat was never honestly faced by either Washington or the media. Ignoring the critical roles played by purported American allies Saudi Arabia and Pakistan in backing the Taliban and al Qaeda meant that the source of the problem was never addressed, and invading a country that had nothing to do with the attacks only opened new opportunities for jihadists.

The inevitable result was “forever wars,” and a loss of trust in government not seen since Watergate.

When these foreign blunders were followed by the worst financial crisis since the Depression, and those responsible were bailed out without suffering any legal penalties, Americans’ patience with mainstream elites snapped. And so they were vulnerable to the disruptive showmanship of a demagogue who promised to make the country “great again,” a recurring phenomenon in human history going back to ancient Athens.

Spirit of adventure

Those who voted for Trump lost sight of the fact that, however desirable change may be, anyone elected to lead the country must have the stability and sobriety that comes with understanding that their actions will have consequences for billions of human beings. A narcissistic and volatile fraudster and reality television star was, needless to say, never going to fulfill that basic mandate.

Advertise with us

Yet the pervasiveness of celebrity culture and the relative ease of modern life seduced enough believers who had forgotten that the world is a fundamentally dangerous place, and that strength of character is the first qualification for dealing with it.

This was another act of hybris, one which had been foreseen by another great interpreter of classical literature. In 1974 the literary critic Paul Zweig published “The Adventurer,” a profound exploration of that archetype from Odysseus to T.E. Lawrence. He argued that this type of hero, who lives solely to experience mortal risk, has endured in human lore because he is “a source of values” who inspires us to have faith “that mere men can survive the storms of the demonic world.”

Zweig deplored the belittling of adventurers in a contemporary world obsessed with professional success, domesticity, comfort and pleasure, which essentially has forgotten that danger is inherent in human life, and issued a prophetic warning: “The modern world’s dismissal of adventure as an entertaining but minor experience is unprecedented. Few cultures have been so willing to tempt the gods.”

Finding ourselves

The relentless flood of catastrophes that began on 9/​11, which have ranged from lost wars to a near-depression to a pandemic to chaotic authoritarianism in the world’s greatest democracy, has validated Zweig’s vision. Yet none of these crises have been met with the social and cultural discipline and humility that is needed to reverse the tide.

Such a reversal would have to begin with the keystone of tragic thought: an honest self-examination that leads to recognition of what we have done to bring these disasters upon ourselves. To recapture that self-critical spirit, we can do no better than to return to what the Greeks, and their great interpreters such as Benardete and Zweig, have to teach us.

Advertise with us

How we meet the storm of Donald Trump will be yet another opportunity for such discipline. Yet we are running out of last chances.

Vanni Cappelli, a freelance journalist, is the president of the Afghanistan Foreign Press Association and a frequent contributor to the Post-Gazette. His previous article was “The FBI purge could lead to another 9/11.”