The nation’s most selective universities have been waking up to a new reality: The billions of dollars in federal funding that have long sustained them now come with strings attached. The Trump administration has threatened to withhold research funds unless they accede to political demands.

How did the nation’s elite research universities end up so vulnerable? While some blame “woke” campus culture, the roots of this clash go back some 80-plus years. It began when the U.S. first called on scientists for the Manhattan Project to build the atomic bomb.

Once independent

For much of the nation’s history, academic scientists and the federal government had little to do with one another. Edgar Bright Wilson, a chemistry professor at Harvard, warned that government funding would “take away the independence of scientific men.”

As World War II broke out in Europe, Vannevar Bush, a brilliant electrical engineer and the most well-connected scientist in the country, began a remarkable behind-the-scenes campaign to enlist scientists to prepare for war.

Advertise with us

“I was located in Washington, I knew government, and I knew the ropes,” he would later recall. “And I could see that the United States was asleep on the technical end.” He enlisted close allies, including the presidents of Harvard and MIT.

Bush and his allies lobbied President Franklin D. Roosevelt to create a new Office of Scientific Research and Development, or OSRD. Controlled by Bush and other civilian scientists, it nonetheless reported directly to Roosevelt and worked on military objectives, even though it was free of military control.

The funds that flowed through this new agency did not go to the military. They went to university researchers.

As historian Daniel Greenberg notes: “For the first time in the nation’s history, substantial federal funds were going to university laboratories.” Bush wasted no time in setting them to work on a project of national importance: building the bomb and anything else that might help the U.S. win what many believed to be an inevitable clash with Germany and Japan.

Watching Christopher Nolan’s movie “Oppenheimer,” you could be forgiven for thinking that Los Alamos was a military facility. In reality, the academics who agreed to work there only did so after it was turned into a civilian operation largely independent of military control, despite the presence of Gen. Leslie Groves.

Advertise with us

On paper, if not in practice, Los Alamos was a research outpost of the University of California.

The practical lesson

Three universities played a role in building the bomb: UC Berkeley’s Radiation Laboratory, aka the “Rad (radiation) Lab”; Columbia’s Special Alloyed Materials Laboratory; and the University of Chicago’s Metallurgical “Met” Lab.

Other university facilities got smaller pieces of the nuclear pie, along with contracts to develop other weapons and defenses. MIT’s own Rad Lab, for example, played a critical role in developing microwave radar. But building the atomic bomb overshadowed these other contributions.

When scientists witnessed the detonation of the first bomb — the so-called Trinity test that took place on July 16, 1945 — they were shocked and awed by what they had unleashed.

But these same scientists also drew a practical lesson as they went back to their respective universities: Taxpayer money, generously applied, could generate staggering scientific advances.

Advertise with us

In 1945, Bush published a book titled “Science: The Endless Frontier,” which argued for massive government investment in research that would take place within the nation’s top universities.

“I realized that science would fall flat on its face after the war if the government didn’t keep up its support,” he later recalled. For the next decade, he and his allies — most of them alumni of the Manhattan Project — began building agencies that would deliver this vision.

It took well over a decade to see results, but the creation of the National Science Foundation, the National Institutes of Health and other parts of a new federal bureaucracy would make the nation’s research universities the envy of the world. Under this system, Congress allocated funds for basic research, but scientists largely determined how that money would be spent.

In 1953, the federal government spent $15.72 billion (in 2022 dollars) on non-defense scientific research and development, with much of it flowing to universities. By 1968, that number reached $102.91 billion, and by 2022, $190.93 billion.

This research support has enabled the nation’s top universities to thrive because the funding underwrites the direct costs of research and the larger indirect expenses associated with keeping a university running.

Advertise with us

Trump understood

This entire system, though, has made every major research university dangerously dependent on federal funding. President Donald Trump, who has built a career on exploiting the weakness of his adversaries, apparently grasped this reality before the universities did.

He understood that if you can find a way to freeze funding, even the wealthiest, most generously endowed private universities cannot function without sustaining grievous losses.

As a consequence, Harvard and its peers are in a no-win situation: They can bow to Trump’s demands, which will intensify no matter how much they do to placate the president. Or they can cut themselves off from the funds that have sustained their rise to greatness.

Either way, though, they should understand that their predicament is less about DEI programs or campus clashes than a decades-long financial dependence upon the government born at the dawn of the atomic age.

Stephen Mihm, a professor of history at the University of Georgia, is coauthor of “Crisis Economics.”