The state’s financial watchdog, the Independent Fiscal Office, has said that our state’s general fund will be entirely expended by the next fiscal year if new revenue is not found. And Gov. Josh Shapiro has found two new sources, but one of the sources will not be worth the cost to vulnerable citizens of the state. On marijuana, Pennsylvania shouldn’t inhale.
In his recent budget address, he proposed legalizing gambling through skill games and slot machines and legalizing recreational marijuana as significant new revenue sources for the state. Politicians lacking the courage to raise taxes or cut spending is so typical as to become a cliche, but raising money on the backs of gamblers and addicts to cover that lack of courage is something much darker.
Exploiting the 10%
Gov. Shapiro has estimated that taxes from a sales tax on marijuana would bring in $250 million in the first year and up to $1.3 billion in the first five years. In order to reach the tax goals that Shapiro hopes to achieve, Pennsylvania’s legal apparatus would need to sell over 25.5 million eighths of pot per year. (An “eighth” is an eighth of an ounce, which produces several joints.)
To put that in perspective, the ten million Pennsylvanians over 21 would need to smoke more than 250 million joints per year to reach those levels of revenue. The idea that every college student, their parents, and their grandparents will all light up twice a month is absurd, of course. What will happen is that half will not consume any marijuana at all, and 10%, or one million Pennsylvanians, will become daily habitual users.
These statistics bear themselves out again and again in surveys on drug use. That small minority is the group the governor will make his revenue targets on. Is it right to help fix the state’s budget by exploiting one group?
It will be a real problem for the state and some of its citizens. The narrative surrounding marijuana has shifted dramatically over the past decade, and recent data suggests a troubling reality. Studies have indicated that increased accessibility and potency of cannabis correlate with a rise in cannabis use disorder (CUD).
According to the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration (SAMHSA), from 2018 to 2022, the most recent data available, CUD has remained at about 10% of all treatment admissions, ahead of cocaine and behind alcohol, opioids and meth.
If you are a millennial, the marijuana you smoked in college had a potency of about 3 to 5%, which holds true for all strains before about the year 2000. Today you can buy 90% THC vapes and commercial strains routinely contain four to five times the THC as earlier products. (THC is tetrahydrocannabinol, the primary psychoactive agent in marijuana.)
This increase in potency has been linked to adverse effects such as paranoia, drug-induced psychosis and a higher likelihood of developing dependency.
The social costs
Any anticipated tax revenue must be weighed against potential societal costs.
In states like Colorado and Washington, where marijuana has been legal since 2012, initial promises of significant tax income have been tempered by unforeseen expenses related to public health, regulation, and law enforcement. According to the CDC, from 2019 to 2022, the number of emergency room visits for children 10 and under involving THC tripled.
Examining the experiences of neighboring states offers valuable insights. (The availability of recreational marijuana in neighboring states is one of the arguments often advanced for legalizing it here: They’re making money and we should too.)
In New Jersey, the rollout of legal marijuana has faced criticism for its slow implementation and regulatory challenges. The New Jersey Cannabis Regulatory Commission has been scrutinized for delays and a lack of diversity in license approvals, leading to a proliferation of unregulated dispensaries and complicating enforcement efforts.
In New York, Gov. Kathy Hochul is currently trying to claw back the initial $50 million of a planned $200 million investment in social justice dispensary investments. The program did succeed in opening the planned number of shops and has been accused by those it has invested in of trapping them in debt.
Relying on marijuana legalization as a fiscal strategy raises ethical questions. The pursuit of tax revenue from a substance associated with potential health risks suggests a willingness to prioritize financial gain over public well-being. This approach mirrors the historical trajectory of the tobacco and alcohol industries, where economic interests often overshadowed health considerations.
Moreover, the assumption that legalization will eradicate illicit markets has proven overly optimistic. High taxes and regulatory hurdles have inadvertently sustained black markets in several states as consumers seek more affordable alternatives.
California’s legalization efforts have encountered obstacles. The state continues to grapple with issues related to unregulated sales and public health concerns.
Despite an established marketplace and many purveyors, two out of every three purchases in 2023 were from an illicit rather than a licensed dealer. This not only undermines legal businesses but also perpetuates the very issues legalization aims to resolve.
When the governor wakes up
In state budgets, as in life, there is no such thing as a free lunch. While Gov. Shapiro might have the munchies for the potential tax revenues now, in the morning he will wake up with the regret that comes from indulging and seeing the damage it did.
What is a government for if not to safeguard the welfare of its citizens? That includes those who will not be able to regulate their use of recreational drugs. Surely whatever proposals the Governor wishes to fund are not worth the cost in suffering and lives that come from addiction.
Chris McGuinn, a former official in the Bush and Trump Administrations, is the founder of More Than 28, which advocates for expanded insurance coverage for addiction treatment.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.