With more than 25,000 children on waiting lists for childcare across the Commonwealth, and many more families needing it who know they can’t afford it, it would seem a paradox that childcare facilities are closing.

How could a service that’s in such demand not be growing? I am the owner and director of a bilingual pre-K childcare center that’s typical of childcare facilities throughout Pennsylvania, and can explain this.

Credentials and costs

Although education has become the focus of pre-school childcare in Pennsylvania, this profession is regulated by an agency within the Department of Human Services, called the Office of Child Development and Early Learning.

The OCDEL’s credentialing and monitoring arm certifies every legitimate childcare facility in the Commonwealth, making sure that staffers are appropriately educated and credentialed, that physical premises are clean and safe, and that the facilities’ programs — social, nutritional, recreational and educational — are age-appropriate. Follow-up is frequent and often unannounced.

Advertise with us

Importantly, child-to-staff ratios are mandated by this governmental body. For example, from one to six children 2 to 3 years old will require one staff member. This arm of OCDEL is appropriate and effective.

While some private childcare facilities in Pennsylvania cater only to prosperous families, most of us also accept some children whose fees are subsidized by the Commonwealth. The financial arm of OCDEL administers this subsidy program, the parents being responsible for paying the difference between the allotment and a childcare’s fees.

The total charges levied by the institution are the same for subsidized children as for those receiving no governmental assistance, by state law. Crucially, a qualifying child is subsidized as an individual, with no consideration for the staffing needs that she or he generates.

For example, the facility must pay a staffer capable of caring for six two year olds must a full salary if just one subsidized two year old shows up, but OCDEL reimburses the facility only for that one child. Such practices will not adequately support the financial needs of a modern childcare system.

Too little pay

While my facility is licensed to care for 32 children ages birth to 5 years old at a time, I average only 10 children daily because of staffing limitations. Median payment for each child is $300 a week.

Advertise with us

Working 40 hours a week, one of my two staffers makes $10 an hour and the other (a teacher) makes $13. I make $680 a week, working far more than 40 hours.

The state has expanded the subsidized child pool, increased subsidies for eligible families, and given tax breaks to companies facilitating childcare. That’s all good, but these initiatives increase the number of children seeking my services, but none improves my ability to accommodate them.

A child care facility needs to be compensated by OCDEL for the staffers required to supervise the children, not on an individual child-by-child basis. If the state wants enough childcare to meet the need, especially for people who cannot afford the fees, it must enable childcare facilities to pay competitive wages.

OCDEL made an apparent attempt to help rectify this situation. It established the STARS program, with four levels, to recognize quality improvements in childcare facilities. It was sold to us providers as a stepwise mechanism to “receive a higher reimbursement rate” and “serve more children.”

Seeing this as a pathway to provide better salaries and gain more staffers, I spent many hours from April to October 2024 to advance my program from STAR-1 to STAR-3 status. Thereafter, I discovered that OCDEL had, as of Aug. 1, 2024, decided that the extra funding I had worked so hard to secure for my program would be used, instead, to increase the subsidies for children attending my facility.

Advertise with us

The state’s blindness

In other words, my facility itself would receive no direct supplemental funding. In order to capture those extra monies being given to subsidized families, I would have to increase the current high cost of childcare for everyone, for private-pay — many of whom are already financially over-stretched — as well as subsidized children at my center.

The legislature and the governor seem blind to the fact that the “childcare crisis” in Pennsylvania is rooted in a lack of providers, not in a paucity of eligible children, and that lack is rooted in the providers’ inability to pay competitive wages. As long as we facility owners cannot offer reasonable wages to attract and retain qualified staffers, the gap between supply and demand (and that demand represents real need) will continue to widen.

Ivelisse Eufracio-Childs is the owner and director of the Little All Stars Care Center in West Hazleton.