The year 2024 ended much the same way that it began: the Steelers once again had a winning record but need to step it up to win a playoff game; and the proposed Nippon Steel acquisition of U.S. Steel remained caught in a political and personal tangle that threatens real economic benefits for workers and the region.
This may not be the last time this happens for the Steelers, but everyone knew it would be the last time for a deal that could save steel-making in southwest Pennsylvania.
Throughout his term, President Joe Biden has repeatedly described himself as the most pro-labor president in history. He had a chance to show workers that he really is on their side by approving the deal — or that he isn’t.
He needed to ensure that “America has a strong domestically owned and operated steel industry that can continue to power our national sources of strength at home and abroad,” he said in a statement. This required him “to block foreign ownership of this vital American company ... on behalf of America’s national interests.”
Attractive investment
Nippon Steel had made numerous commitments, including new ones that addressed the government’s concern about declining domestic steel output.
It pledged not to reduce production capacity at U.S. Steel facilities in Pennsylvania and other states for 10 years without federal approval; to have a majority U.S. citizen board; and to invest billions of dollars into aging facilities, with at least $1 billion going to the Mon Valley Works.
The company offered exactly the kind of foreign investment that presidents and governors usually go to great lengths to attract and celebrate. Just six months ago, for instance, the White House issued a report heralding how “investors with headquarters in foreign countries accounted for over 45 percent (58 billion) of the value of new clean energy manufacturing investment announcements in 2022 and 2023” in the U.S.
The same report noted that the biggest share of those investments — over one-third — came from Japan, which it described as one of “our closest trading partners and strategic allies.”
But what should have been even more important to a self-described pro-worker president is Nippon’s commitment to protect jobs. The company promised that it would institute no layoffs or plant closures.
Compare this to what is likely to happen now. U.S. Steel CEO David Burritt has said that it is probable that many jobs would need to be eliminated, while other positions would move to the South, where U.S. Steel has growing, modern steel mills.
That’s why local union leaders said in December that 95% of union members at U.S. Steel’s Irvin Works in West Mifflin support the deal. And it’s why hundreds of Mon Valley steelworkers rallied in freezing December weather to demand that the government not throw away a lifeline. It was their latest display of support, having organized a similar showing in the fall.
Local mayors also plead for the deal’s approval, knowing economic devastation could follow without it. “We need to get this deal done. If not, the Mon Valley is dead,” Clairton Mayor Richard Lattanzi said recently.
Since the deal was announced, the major obstacle was the United Steelworkers’ leadership. The union’s president David McCall has repeatedly rebuffed Nippon Steel’s outreach to iron out disagreements and formalize commitments.
Instead, he has aligned himself with Cleveland-Cliffs CEO Lourenco Goncalves, whose company was outbid by Nippon and who is committed to scuttling the deal. Goncalves’ desire to try to acquire U.S. Steel again is well known.
Some suspected that McCall’s real loyalties lie with Cliffs, and that he is willing to undermine a superior deal to help the Ohio steelmaker. McCall “openly campaigned” for Cliffs’ bid for U.S. Steel. He also previously led the USW’s Ohio district, and he remains a member of a USW local in Cleveland where Cliffs is based.
A good deal
But despite McCall’s vehement opposition, other USW leaders sided with the employees who are most at risk. “This incredible deal will solidify our jobs for decades to come,” Jason Zugai, a local United Steelworkers union leader, said at the December rally. “We need the politicians to understand how this deal will affect our jobs, our families and our communities.”
Countless analyses find that the deal would strengthen U.S. national security, save jobs, especially jobs in southwest Pennsylvania, and bolster American steelmaking and manufacturing — especially relative to China. It would have served our national interests to have a stronger U.S. Steel and a more competitor steel industry.
The USW’s president may have stood with U.S. Steel’s competitor. But that was not a good reason for jeopardizing thousands of jobs and devastating steelmaking communities.
Rather than worrying about politics or catering to union leadership, Joe Biden should have sided with the rank-and-file workers whose livelihoods may hinge on the deal’s approval. He didn’t.
Jeffrey Kupfer, an adjunct faculty member at Carnegie Mellon University’s Heinz College, was a special assistant to President George W. Bush for economic policy.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.