With Donald Trump still refusing to admit he lost the 2020 election and justifying his efforts to overturn the result, and his vice presidential candidate JD Vance supporting the false claims that Democrats stole the election, Americans should understand why that still matters.
It matters because the most essential power in a democracy — more consequential than picking good leaders, advancing good policies, or anything else — is the ability to peacefully remove bad leaders. That is the quality that keeps democracies alive.
Thus the record of whether a political leader accepted voters’ power to remove them the last time around obviously has a bearing on whether they would accept it in the future. Asked about the election, Trump continues to lie about whether he lost and calls it “old news.”
When Vance is asked who won, he dodges by saying, “I’m focused on the future,” or “The media’s obsessed with talking about the election of four years ago. I’m focused on the election of 33 days from now, because I want to throw Kamala Harris out of office.”
The most essential power
Why is voters’ ability to throw out bad leaders the most essential power in a democracy? This argument is grounded in the 20th century’s most influential defense of liberal democracy: British philosopher Karl Popper’s famous critique of the Greek philosopher Plato and his idea of an authoritarian “republic” led by philosopher kings, published in 1945.
When European powers were slaughtering millions in World War II — human fallibility at its worst — Popper praised democracy as the only form of government reliably capable of dismissing terrible rulers without bloodshed. He viewed most political leaders as mediocre and dismissed the ability to select good leaders — Plato’s philosopher kings — as overrated by voters and elites who think too highly of their own predictive abilities.
Given that voters and leaders are fallible, he argued, the best way to peacefully avoid revolutions, coups, war, persecution, terror, famine, and squalor is not just through free and fair elections. It’s through elections, and this is crucial, upheld by institutions that are too robust to be dismantled by autocratic leaders before voters correct their own mistake of electing them into office in the first place.
History has proven Popper right. Over the eight decades since he wrote, stable democracies under the rule of law delivered the most peaceful and prosperous era of human history. Civil societies, businesses, and political leaders achieved long-term gains in human rights and economic wellbeing.
No modern democracy has ever collapsed at an income level higher than $18,000 (the level in today’s currency at which Argentina suffered a military coup in 1975). On security decisions, democracies made tragic mistakes (think the U.S. wars in Vietnam and Iraq), but they never waged war against each other.
Democracies vs. tyrannies
All these positive results in open societies are because, in democracies, leaders are motivated to consider the views of the whole population, and if they don’t, they soon get thrown out of office.
By contrast, the worst mass atrocities of the past century — Hitler’s Holocaust, Stalin’s Red Famine and Great Purge, Mao’s Cultural Revolution and Great Leap Forward, Putin’s war in Ukraine, Xi’s repressive regime of surveillance and concentration camps, and more than a dozen other genocides around the world — were all perpetrated by rulers who were not accountable to voters.
Three of those dictators remained in power for at least a decade before dying in office (Hitler ruled for 12 years, Stalin 29 and Mao 27). The people of their countries had and have no ability to change the direction of the country by removing their political leaders.
They lacked free and fair elections. The two living ones are currently on track to do the same, for the same reason.
After Donald Trump lost the 2020 election, American institutions proved robust. The responsible government agencies defended the electoral system and the courts rejected Trump’s claims. The vice president and Congress did their duty in certifying the election, despite a mob’s invasion of the capital.
The threat to our institutions
But how long will the institutions prove robust, if half the nation believes the other half controls them and will even use the electoral system to overthrow the people’s will? When alienated citizens threaten violence because they believe the system is rigged against them? How do we defend our institutions against such threats?
It takes more than four years to consolidate power beyond the reach of voters and the rule of law. All but one of the dictators named above — Hitler pulled it off just four weeks into the job — needed five to 10 years to thoroughly purge any real opposition and dismantle the institutions that enshrine the transition of power.
It takes time to install enough pliant yes-men to deploy prosecutors and the military against political opponents and anyone else who stands in the way, as Trump promised to do this week against “the enemy within.”
What happened in 2020 matters in 2024, not just because Trump is at it again, suggesting he may not accept a defeat if he loses again while he and his allies spread lies about massive non-citizen voting and other supposed widespread irregularities in the 2024 election.
It also matters for 2028 and beyond, given that nobody should be surprised if a president who previously tried to thwart the peaceful transfer of power attempts to do so again, robbing Americans of their most essential role in a democracy.
Josh Rudolph is senior fellow of the German Marshall Fund of the United States and head of its Transatlantic Democracy Working Group.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.