Some people remember where they were when man first walked on the moon. Others can recall where they were when they first heard the Beatles. Me, I can tell you exactly where I was the first time I ever saw a copy of MAD Magazine.

I was riding in the back of a bus on the way home from school and there was an older kid reading MAD #127 (June 1969).

The cover featured the then wildly popular show “The Mod Squad,” or as MAD called it, “The Odd Squad.” Front and center on the cover was MAD’s gap-toothed, grinning mascot, Alfred E. Neuman, morphed into one of the show’s three main characters, Linc, portrayed by actor Clarence Williams III, complete with his darker skin and enormous round afro.

In MAD-speak, this is known as an Alfred substitution gag, though there is no real gag per se, just the mixing of Alfred with another character while others from the show react, either in horror or disgust. It’s a trope MAD used many times over the years, because it was an efficient way to communicate to newsstand buyers in a nano second what was being spoofed in the issue.

Advertise with us

But there was something about this particular cover, illustrated by artist Jack Rickard, that drew me in and made me laugh out loud. It was a love at first sight gag. I went to a local newsstand (kids, ask your parents) and bought my first copy of MAD. (35 cents. Cheap!)

MAD gave voice

Like so many young MAD readers, once exposed to the magazine, I couldn’t get enough. I scoured flea markets and used book stores for back issues as I impatiently waited for the new issue to arrive every six weeks on the newsstand. (I never subscribed. I always wanted the option of picking the most pristine copy from the stack on sale.)

I pored over the issues, usually starting with easily-accessible features such as the Don Martin cartoons, Dave Berg’s “Lighter Side of …” and Sergio Aragones’ “A MAD Look At …” before tackling the heavier reading pieces such as the movie satires and MAD primers. I didn’t always understand all the jokes, but I instinctively knew that some adult sacred cows, such as big tobacco or the military industrial complex, were being slaughtered and, for some reason, that alone was enough to bring me joy and satisfaction.

The magazine gave voice to thoughts, ideas and suspicions I had long harbored in my young mind but never had the courage to actually say out loud: just because they’re my parent and teachers doesn’t mean they’re always right; most politicians are lying blowhards; advertisers will say anything in their commercials just to get you to buy their lousy products.

In issue after issue, MAD was there telling me the truth, exposing the hypocrisy and B.S. and pointing out the often ridiculousness and absurdity of life. The not-so-subtle message of the magazine was: Challenge authority; think for yourself. Brushing up against this message was the magazine’s cover boy, Alfred E. Neuman (the “E” stands for “enigma”), ever smiling and, with his trademark slogan, “What — me worry?” offering readers a glimmer of optimism and hope no matter how dire the situation.

Advertise with us

Like so many other MAD readers I’ve spoken to over the years, I never threw away my old issues and would often take them out and reread them, discovering references and double entendres that went over my head in previous readings. And, of course, I was always on the lookout for “chicken fat,” artist Will Elder’s term for the background gags that littered the cluttered panels of the magazine. MAD rewarded readers who paid attention.

In no time, I became familiar with all of MAD’s contributors, aka “The Usual Gang of Idiots.” MAD bylines were the names of friends I’d never met but with whom I felt I held a special, secret bond.

I could immediately recognize the art styles of Mort Drucker, Al Jaffee, Jack Davis, Paul Coker and all the other MAD cartoonists and illustrators. But, being an aspiring MAD writer, I could also recognize the writing styles and comedic sensibilities of the different writers, Frank Jacobs, Arnie Kogen, Dick DeBartolo, Tom Koch, the list goes on. Indeed, to read an issue of MAD carefully was akin to taking a master class in comedy writing, its form, structure and payoff.

Guiding principles

Years later, when I became an associate editor at MAD, I quickly learned that much of how I read the magazine and grew into its content wasn’t by accident, it was by design, set forth in three guiding principles.

1) Never take a demographic survey of the readership. Publisher Bill Gaines feared that if we learned that the average MAD reader was a 17-year-old male, the writers, artists and editors might subconsciously start pandering its material to that readership and MAD would lose its specialness.

Advertise with us

Our mail told us that we certainly had an eclectic readership. We routinely received crayon drawings from the very young, plus both funny and heartfelt letters from teens, adults and those in nursing homes. Also, doctors, lawyers, college professors, celebrities, clergymen and prison inmates. Every one of these readers sincerely believed the magazine was being edited for them and their interests, a real testament to Al Feldstein’s and Nick Meglin’s editing skills.

2) Never write down to the readers. MAD editors always assumed that their readers were as smart as they were, probably smarter. (Some might say that’s a low bar.) We never wrote down either in subject matter or references. We published what we thought was interesting and funny and hoped that our readers would find it interesting and funny, too.

If a younger reader didn’t understand a particular joke, that was OK. There were plenty more in the issue they could understand.

However, each issue of MAD was carefully balanced with a mixture of broad and sophisticated, visual and more copy driven, verse, political, whimsical and just plain silly humor. Sports, music, movies, TV shows, advertising and the folly of life in America were all reflected back in what Meglin once called “MAD’s funhouse mirror.”

3) Never do victim humor. MAD was a champion of the underdog. You won’t find jokes at the expense of sick or homeless people in MAD, but you will find plenty of jokes, observations and flat-out insults about the corrupt politicians, greedy drug companies and others in power who failed in their responsibility to help those less fortunate. MAD never punched down.

Advertise with us

John Ficarra was the longtime editor of MAD magazine. This is a slightly abridged version of his essay for the catalog for “What, Me Worry? The Art and Humor of Mad Magazine,” an exhibit at the Norman Rockwell Museum in Stockbridge, Mass., running through Oct. 27. For more information, visit NRM.org.

The illustrations are from the James Halperin Collection, courtesy of Heritage Auctions. MAD and all related elements ™ & © E.C. Publications. Courtesy of DC. All Rights Reserved. Used with permission.