
Rabbi Mark Asher Goodman hoped he could bring guidance to the lanky teenager who entered his Intro to Judaism class at Congregation Beth Shalom back in 2018.
“He seemed like a young, confused man in search of some direction,” Rabbi Goodman recalled. “He was inquisitive, but he sometimes struggled with the ideas of Judaism that revolved around inclusivity, tolerance, love and kindness.”
He had no idea that his eager new student would go on to lie, steal and deceive members of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community in a campaign of harassment that lasted nearly half a decade.
Andrew Clinton eventually stopped attending Rabbi Goodman’s course after becoming combative with other students.
“You asked whether I saw warning signs. The answer is yeah, I did,” Rabbi Goodman said. “But I thought he would straighten out.”
Mr. Clinton’s seeming fixation with Pittsburgh’s Jewish community played out in bizarre ways. He tried to convert with at least six different rabbis, all of whom eventually turned him away. He spent hours learning Hebrew and studying Jewish teachings with community members, but then used these new relationships to steal money and possessions.
While many in the Jewish community welcomed him, others say his overtures took advantage of an idealistic openness that has persisted despite the Tree of Life synagogue shooting and continued antisemitic threats and violence.
“Did he want to be part of a community? Or did he want to be part of a community because it gave him easy access to people who he could harm?” Rabbi Goodman said. “I don’t know the answer.”
Bizarre crimes
Andrew Clinton, now 22, of Natrona Heights, was sentenced to a maximum of six years in prison in May 2023. It was far from his first time in court.
Since 2020, he has faced at dozens of charges of theft, property damage and disorderly conduct. He had collected over 300 pieces of Judaica in his home by the time police searched the residence.
But Mr. Clinton’s erratic behavior went beyond stealing: He often adopted different personas, sometimes identifying himself as a Carnegie Mellon or University of Pittsburgh student, and on other occasions as a contractor or HVAC technician to get closer with strangers or make his way into their homes.
“It’s a very warm community, a very accepting community, and this was just an absolute betrayal and abuse of trust."
He wasn’t a naturally gifted liar, but he was prolific. I interviewed at least seven of his victims in 2022, some of whom said they believed him just because it was hard to understand why someone would lie so carelessly, and so often, about their own identity. They described a lost young man with impulsive, predatory and often contradictory tendencies.
Mr. Clinton himself isn’t publicity shy. In the summer of 2022, I contacted him on Facebook Messenger. To my surprise, he answered almost immediately. What followed were the most baffling conversations of my career. A thin young man with bright blue eyes and blond hair, Mr. Clinton speaks earnestly and with a slight lisp. He denies many of the accusations and confesses to others, but always claims his intentions were misunderstood.
Meanwhile, in Squirrel Hill, feelings of betrayal are evident.
“It’s a very warm community, a very accepting community, and this was just an absolute betrayal and abuse of trust,” said Shawn Brokos, the community security director for the Jewish Federation of Greater Pittsburgh. She first began hearing concerns about Mr. Clinton from rabbis and community members in January 2021.
“We have a community that’s still reeling from the events of [the Tree of Life synagogue] shooting,” she said. “People still very much carry that trauma.”
The shooting, in which a man entered a Squirrel Hill synagogue and killed 11 people in October 2018, was the deadliest antisemitic attack in U.S. history.
“Something like this … it brings that trauma back,” Ms. Brokos said.

Getting caught
Mr. Clinton was not an adept criminal. He made simple mistakes, like getting his car caught in the mud near a house he’d broken into, or giving out his real name while doing illicit business.
Deborah Gespass, 67, of Squirrel Hill, first encountered Mr. Clinton in January 2021 while walking her puppy with her husband at Frick Park, just blocks from her home on Glen Forest Drive.
Mr. Clinton stopped to pet the black-and-white puppy named Daphne. Just seconds later, he unhooked her collar, scooped her into his arms, and ran.
Daphne was found the next day at Blue Slide Park, wandering without a collar, and was returned to her home.
A week later, Ms. Gespass visited Petland Village at East Side — the same store where she’d rescued Daphne at 8 weeks old. Marci Caplan, the franchise owner, was a friend.
Ms. Caplan told her about a strange customer who had come in the same day that Daphne had been taken, claiming to be Israeli like Ms. Caplan. He didn’t have a pet with him and didn’t know the age or breed of his own dog.
But he’d opened a rewards program and filled out his name: Andrew Clinton.
After a negotiated plea deal, Mr. Clinton pled guilty to disorderly conduct and criminal mischief in November 2021 and was sentenced to probation. As part of the deal, all details of the dog-napping were scrubbed from his record.
Another blunder five months later led police to find a horde of Judaica in Mr. Clinton’s home. Early one March morning in 2022, Mr. Clinton’s sedan got caught in the mud adjacent to the Pittsburgh Field Club golf course in Fox Chapel.
When an officer arrived, Mr. Clinton gave him an ID that was severely damaged. He said he’d mangled the card himself so he could use it “to enter doors.” Nevertheless, the officer let him go.
That night, 911 dispatchers received a report of a residential burglary only blocks away from the home where the car had been stuck. Security camera footage showed a thin young man matching Mr. Clinton’s description.
Discovering the Judaica
Days after Mr. Clinton was stranded in his car, officers executed a search warrant on the Squirrel Hill home he rented.
What they discovered went far beyond the items reported in the home invasion. Over 300 Jewish religious objects — including large paintings, menorahs, knives with Hebrew lettering, a ram’s horn, miniature Israeli flags and a rabbi’s personal diploma — were stored in the home.

According to Detective Francisco Rosato with the Pittsburgh Police, the department soon realized resolving the case might prove more difficult than they first imagined. Mr. Clinton had a gift for dodging questions and giving long, nonsensical answers.
“The county police … interviewed him, I believe, for five hours,” Detective Rosato said. “And by the time it was done, they got absolutely nowhere. Their notepad was empty.
“He was just talking and talking about nothing.”
Detective Rosato, a lifelong Pittsburgher who has spent more than two decades with the city police force, first heard about Mr. Clinton when a county officer reached out to him after the Judaica was discovered.
At the time, Detective Rosato didn’t realize that he was, in fact, already investigating Mr. Clinton in a case of home improvement fraud involving a Jewish couple. Mr. Clinton was such a prolific petty criminal he’d accidentally involved both police forces.
Devoted to faith
Mr. Clinton, born Andrew Tolusciak, grew up near Natrona Heights and attended Highlands High School, graduating in 2020 and moving to Squirrel Hill shortly thereafter.
“Ever since I was a kid, I was interested in God and stuff,” he said of his early interest in Judaism. He said his father is Jewish, though police have said that’s inaccurate. He described the Judaica in his home as “investments.”
“Not financial investments, but investments with God,” he said. “To bring me closer to God, to do what I believe is right.”
He also maintained that every religious item was purchased, not stolen.
Police disagree, alleging that Mr. Clinton is responsible for burglarizing Pinskers, a Murray Avenue store that specializes in Jewish art, books and religious items. Some of the items in his home still had Pinskers tags on them.
Mr. Clinton devoted significant time and energy to learning about the religion and its teachings.
He spent hours in recorded YouTube conversations with Manis Friedman, a well-known rabbi with a following of over 200,000 subscribers. They discussed Jewish perspectives on morality, happiness and overcoming trauma.
From early 2020 until the summer of 2021, Mr. Clinton consulted at least six Pittsburgh-area rabbis from various congregations with the goal of converting. Eventually, every interaction soured or was broken off.
There is no record that Mr. Clinton successfully converted, despite his claims otherwise to multiple people. Nevertheless, he is angered by anyone who questions his Jewish identity.
“Who are they to say that I’m not Jewish? Who are they to say that? Do they have a degree in Halakhah? In Jewish law? No, they don’t. I spent years studying Torah,” he said.
Growing alarm
Ms. Brokos, the security director, first heard about a concerning young man from local rabbis in January 2021, the same month as the Frick Park dog-napping.
In just six months, three rabbis had come to her with complaints about Mr. Clinton’s erratic behavior and what one rabbi described as a fixation with Judaism.
Another rabbi said it was hard to discern whether Mr. Clinton absolutely loved the Jewish community — or absolutely hated them.
“The problem is, even if he did tell us the truth, I don’t think we’d believe him.”
Ms. Brokos, who worked for the FBI for over two decades, began digging into Mr. Clinton’s background in earnest.
She quickly verified that he wasn’t a student at CMU or Pitt. In fact, Ms. Brokos said Mr. Clinton had been banned from the CMU campus. Ms. Brokos began sounding the alarm in other agencies within the community, sending out flyers with his description.
In February 2022, Mr. Clinton called Ms. Brokos, accusing her of disparaging his reputation. He was especially agitated that he had been banned from posting in “Jewish Pittsburgh,” a Facebook group for the community where he’d been an active member.
He said the ban was costing him valuable contracting business.
He was also angry Ms. Brokos told community members about his criminal record, and especially about the fact that he’d been arrested before.
Ms. Brokos replied: “Well, Andrew, you have been arrested before.”
Ousted from the community
As Mr. Clinton sat on his Squirrel Hill porch in June 2022, he said that many neighbors began avoiding him since his arrests. At Giant Eagle, someone had stopped to tell him they wanted to punch him.
“I still feel at home here. I just think there’s a lot of damage, and a lot of people are scared,” he said. “I’m not sure I have the emotional energy to try to build all the bridges that were burned.”
At the time of that interview, Mr. Clinton was out on probation after being released on $20,000 bail. That winter, he would attempt break-ins at another series of homes, leading to the sentence in May 2023.
For some of the rabbis who knew him, Mr. Clinton’s behavior has interfered with carrying out the fundamentally welcoming tenets of Judaism.
“One of the things that’s written on the base of almost every church and synagogue in America is, ‘My house will be a house of prayer for all,’” said Rabbi Goodman.
“How can it be a house of prayer for all if you have to be suspicious about every person who walks through the door?” he said.
Months after the dog-napping incident with Daphne, Mr. Clinton approached Ms. Gespass at a local Giant Eagle. She was surprised he had recognized her at all, even after their court case.
“He was talking really fast and he was apologizing,” Ms. Gespass said. But she wasn’t interested in hearing his explanations.
“The problem is, even if he did tell us the truth, I don’t think we’d believe him.”
Rebecca Spiess is an associate editorial page editor for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: rspiess@post-gazette.com or on X at RebeccaSpiessL.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.