CARLISLE, PA  —  At the end of the ceremony welcoming the new Army War College class of 2024 to the Carlisle Barracks, the U.S. Army Band concluded the day with the Army Song, and by the time the band hit the verse “Then its Hi! Hi! Hey! The Army’s on its way!” everyone in the stands — members of all of the branches of the U.S. military, their families, and their new classmates from 75 different countries from across the globe — had risen to their feet and were all singing along, some in salute, some in tears, all with pride.

Major General David C. Hill, the 53rd Commandant of the U.S. Army War College, felt emotional after the ceremony. A Pittsburgh native who left for West Point in 1986 and served in his first unit in Saudi Arabia during Desert Shield, before going on to serve in a half dozen states and dozens of countries in command battalions and brigades, he said his opportunity to lead now as a general officer here in his home state is truly a privilege.

“We are the custodians of a tradition that builds a community with each other and with civilians. It is something that has been happening here at Carlisle since 1951, when the Army College was moved here and back to the inception of the Army War College in 1901 when it was founded,” he said. The War College began during Theodore Roosevelt’s presidency and was moved out of Washington to the Carlisle Barracks, the nation’s second-oldest military base, after the second World War.

The stands at the Indian Field were packed last Monday with members representing all of the United States Armed Forces, as well as their families. Members of militaries from 75 different countries will be part of the 2024 class. (USAWC Staff)

Nestled in the Susquehanna Valley just a handful of miles off of the Pennsylvania Turnpike, this facility, which had its beginnings during the French and Indian War, is considered the home of the top military and strategic training program in the world. The college has approximately 79 buildings on 447 bucolic acres and houses more than 3,000 men, women and their families.

Advertise with us

They spend their down time in the region — which means the War College is an economic driver in the state. As of 2018, the total economic impacts generated by Army operations at Carlisle Barracks created 2,868 jobs within Pennsylvania, generated more than $229 million in labor income annually and $521 million in overall economic output within the state.

Candidates to attend the USAWC are traditionally in the midstream of their career — so about 20 years in — and are invited by a board of military officials in Washington. Most of the U.S. military students have had battleground experience during Operations Iraqi Freedom or Enduring Freedom.

The men and women who study here serve in all branches of the military, including the Coast Guard. Approximately two dozen civilian intelligence officers attend from agencies such as the State Department, FBI, CIA and the National Security Agency, as well as 75 international officers, including some from the war-torn countries of Ukraine and Niger.

The Fife and Drum Corps perform for review during the Opening Day ceremonies at army war college at the Carlisle Barracks in Cumberland County. (USAWC Staff)

Despite its strategic importance and historic significance, few Pennsylvanians know much about what happened here before and what happens here today.

Kevin Dixon, the assistant commandant, said the barracks’ beginnings as a military facility can be traced to before the founding of the country. “A military post was first built here in 1751 because of its ideal location along the Indian trails, which eventually became Forbes Road; it was a half-way point for traders and settlers heading towards the confluence in what was then the edge of the frontier and is now Pittsburgh,” Mr. Dixon explained, adding that it was the British who first established Carlisle as an official military post under Col. John Stanwix during the French and Indian War.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dixon also explained that just months after the signing of the Declaration of Independence, the Continental Congress authorized a magazine to be built here, which eventually became a manufacturing center, laboratory and an arsenal to build cast cannons and ammunition to support the war effort.

Walk the facility, and one discovers that the fieldstone guardhouse constructed by captured Hessian soldiers taken prisoner after the battle of Trenton during the Revolutionary War still stands, perfectly preserved. “Locals at the time began calling the barracks ‘Fort Washingtonburg’ in honor of George Washington,” explained Mr. Dixon.

“Washington was back here in 1794, where he gathered over 10,000 troops with Treasury Secretary Alexander Hamilton to put down the Whiskey Rebellion,” Mr. Dixon explained. “It marked the only time a sitting president led a battle.”

The Army Drill Team performed for review for the Commandant a universal military tradition the dates back to medieval times. (USAWC Staff)

The property was still an armory and recruiting station during the American Civil War, prompting confederate Gen. J.E.B. Stuart to burn the barracks 160 years ago at the start of the Battle of Gettysburg.

“In 1879 the Carlisle Indian Industrial School was established on the grounds and was in existence here for over 39 years,” said Mr. Dixon. The school was known for building famed athletic teams that included Jim Thorpe, who is honored throughout the campus. The gym where he developed his skills under Coach “Pop” Warner is named after him.

Advertise with us

Mr. Dixon said President Theodore Roosevelt’s War Department secretary, Elihu Root, founded the USAWC in 1901 in Washington when America was going from an isolationist country to a world power. “It closed briefly during World War II, moved to Fort Leavenworth, and has been here since 1951,” Mr. Dixon said.

Today Mr. Dixon is walking through the brand-new Root Hall — so new the paint was still being touched up and the faculty were still unpacking their boxes. The new academic facility is filled with warmth and sunlight, a state-of-the art masterpiece in mid-century modern oranges, golds and greens, with adaptable classrooms — one that bears no resemblance to the cold, brutalist architecture of the last century’s government building designs.

Mr. Dixon said he is keenly aware — despite all the good that happens here in teaching military men and women leadership skills, national security policy, stewardship, and exploring the alternatives to targeted killing — that the military has a deep problem with the civilian-military relationship, one of a severity not seen since the Vietnam War.

(USAWC Staff)

Last week’s Gallup poll showed public confidence in the U.S. military has reached its lowest point in nearly three decades with only 60% of Americans expressing a “great deal” of confidence in the military, down from 74% in 2018 who said the same and a drop of 9 points in just the last two years.

“It is something we are deeply worried about,” Mr. Dixon said. One of the War College’s professors, Dr. Carrie Lee, is creating a “civil-military relationship center” to research the issue, he said.

Advertise with us

He said mistrust has become a recruiting challenge “and has increased distance between the society that is served and those that are serving.” He added: “The United States Army War College is uniquely positioned to provide a capability, as we think about it, in terms of thought leadership, about how are we going to sustain this for another 250-plus years as we think about the nation as it moves forward.”

Given the fact only one-half of one percent of this country serves in the military, Mr. Dixon says rebuilding that trust may be the most critical thing they do going forward.

North Side native Salena Zito is a national political reporter for The Washington Examiner, a New York Post columnist and co-author of “The Great Revolt: Inside the Populist Coalition Reshaping American Politics”: zito.salena@gmail.com.